“You’re not the enemy, but underneath you don’t agree.” True, that: The Gossip, this critic has nothing against you, particularly – your upbeat pop-punk has rattled my rib cage in the live environment quite wonderfully these past few years – but I don’t think you’ve enough bona-fide hits in your Standing In The Way Of Control LP of early 2006 to warrant press officer claims that your tabloid-followed trio is an “unstoppable force”. It’s already well established that said album’s title track is its standout moment; this delayed release – put back to allow for another issuing of that song – just sounds tired and, well, boring in comparison.
Now, I’m not saying ‘bad’ – ‘Jealous Girls’ is just fine in the context of its parent album, played at not-quite-ear-splitting levels at a distant relative’s house party – but there really isn’t enough of any of those ‘Standing…’ ingredients here to put it in a similar league of appeal both instantaneous and unexpectedly long-lasting. It tells us nothing new about the Arkansas-spawned outfit, and newcomers to their boisterous soul-punk are likely to summarise them as one-hit-wonders as a result of this single’s one-dimensionality and wholly linear execution. Relatively punchy production from Fugazi stick insect Guy Picciotto raises the bar an inch or two from where it might otherwise lay, but even his efforts here lack the explosiveness evident in his work on the last Blood Brothers album, Young Machetes. A little of that fire here, and we’d be onto a winner.
Without it, though, ‘Jealous Girls’ has ‘scraped the top 40’ written all over it. That next album, that’s what we want; the spectre of ‘Standing…’ demands it.
Spot-on.
They're a great band, but with only truly one great song thus far. A new album would be quite an exciting prospect, and a vital one if they're going to survive.
Although that said, they've survived quite well thus far. So I'm probably wrong. Again.
"Thus far"
I never say that. Why did I say it twice? I hate today.
"only truly one great song thus far"
is utter bullshit. Listen to their back catalogue.
Agreed
Jason's Basement
Rocks.
As does
Night.
yeah...
"Listen Up!" Couldn't resist that...
i'm not happy with this
They wrote a raido friendly stomper by some kind of fluke and now they get compared to it constantly.. it is a great song but should we judge all their others the same.. the knives out for GOXXIP.
I agree, their back catalogue is amazing, and Movement stands head and shoulers above SITWOC..
Also they're being treated like they're some new phenomenon who've got no staying power whatsoever..
Riot grrl was never ment for the mainstream, was it?
Bikini Kill
were better.
was that
ever in dispute?
Whenever I
see the words "riot grrl", it's my stock response.
Previously on...
The Gossip for me will always be the ‘previously on skins’ band. That show did wonders for SITWOC.
Anyone else thinking
one hit wonder?
Yes, me!
I’ve even forgot what single review this is for.
i hope they are a one hit wonder, i do..
so they won't have to bow to much record company pressure to make a shitty and convoluted followup...
did they stick with KRS in the states? i heard they did the major label sign..
i hope they just go away/
bloody skins.
plus ditto is fat, and lisa riley has that demographic pretty much covered.
.....in flab!