In a world where the news is greatly exaggerated to mask the unfaltering boredom of reality, the headline greeting Franz Ferdinand’s new single would surely be:
STOP PRESS!!! Leading Glasgwegian Art-Rock Quartet Re-Record Bemusing Album Track!!! Police Baffled By Choice Of Single!!! Rhythm Section Cheer: “We Have More To Do Now”!!!
In much the same way, the new version of 'Eleanor Put Your Boots On' has been pumped up to disguise the not-particularly-interesting original. A step away from the usual approach employed in Ferdinand’s more successful moments, the re-recording is a light-year ahead of the corresponding version on their second album, You Could Have It So Much Better, as the double-tracked vocals from the original are ditched and the acoustic guitar is mixed down in favour of a more epic feel. As a banjo is airlifted into the fray, the previously silent rhythm section is spurred into mid-tempo action and the piano is elegantly lightened; Captain Kapranos’ tone switches between his usual aloofly-superior stance for the uptempo verse and an excessively dramatic, velvet-soft call for the wistfully-slowed chorus line of “I could be there when you land”, atop a sweeping string section.
Initially a welcome departure from the standard Franz omni-directional hip-thrusting floor-filler, something about this song's execution leaves a bitter aftertaste, the strange feeling of something lacking. Perhaps it's that, whilst the arrangements are taken from their sparse origins and succesfully given a grand makeover, the song beneath just isn’t that strong, and it sits awkwardly because of it. An improved but still below-par taster of what was an arguably disappointing album, 'Eleanor Put Your Boots On' might quickly be forgotten.
I've not heard the new version
but I thought "Eleanor, Put Your Boots Back On" was one of the strongest tracks on "You Can Have It So Much Better".
Mind you, I also still think YCHISM is a better album than the debut which, although instantly catchy, I always felt lacked a little in terms of depth and longetivity.
no talk of the Avalanches remix?
It's rather odd as it basically makes the song so ambient it's non-existent. Pitchfork thought the same today but while I would give it a good rating they gave it 1 star for the same reason.
I wish The Fiery Furnaces would release Police Sweater Blood Vow (Eleanor Friedberger's song for Alex) as it would make a lovely pair of singles and is a really great, poppy song.
that's a remix of Fade Together
as the B Side not EPYBO.
I liked the original version of this
In general, the album is much better than the debut. They seemed a lot more relaxed. Why they feel the need to release this puzzles me though.
that remix
is not on my copy..
I love it.
But you're right about the record. It isn't as good as the debut.
I think the inverse to this review.
I quite like the album version. The production on this new one is really quite irritating. A shame. Fucking banjo indeed.
Plus, isn't it 'I could be there when you land'?
good spot
lord knows how i missed that.
but really, when i heard the album i thought this stood out like a sore thumb, like it had the makings of an epic but the way it was recorded was a bit shoddy.. i guess it all depends on your opinion of the original!