Home / Reviews / Albums /
Beth Rowley: Little Dreamer
Some people are confused by the difference between being technically competent and remotely interesting – just because an artist can hold a note, sing in tune, and comes prepared with a CV as long as their forearm doesn't necessarily mean their output is going to do more than send the average listener to sleep. And who is this average listener? Perhaps: wife and two young sprogs in tow, comfortable office job, reliable diesel-fuelled motor, living on one of those new fangled estates on the rural edge of a city. Gets the horn at the sound of Jo Whiley's voice and goes for a crafty half every Friday after work where he and his work colleagues discuss the merits of this week's Nuts magazine. Sound familiar? Then this album is for you.
It’s slick so far as the production goes, and there's no doubt that Beth Rowley will turn just as many heads by her pleasing appearance as she will her vocal styling, which seems to be based on any number of artists from the past without ever really creating much in the way of an identity for herself.
Having raised her profile somewhat thanks to a supporting role on David Gray's last major UK tour, Rowley is now being touted as the "more genuine article" where British bluesy songstresses are concerned. But there is something resoundingly distasteful about Little Dreamer, so blatantly obvious from a marketing perspective – it could be the strategically divided track selection between cover versions and "co-written" originals, but something screams “Only £6.99 at Tesco” in big, bold, blue and white barcode-imitating stripes.
Most arrangements are the work of long-term associate and collaborator Duke Special, and each and every one breeds a familiarity you'd expect from having tea with an elder statesman of the family, from the opening traditional standard 'Nobody's Fault But Mine', to the cover of Bob Dylan's 'I Shall Be Released', which sounds like Karen Carpenter taking on cod reggae. It’s on the more accentuated blues numbers like 'Only One Cloud' and the gospel-tinged 'Almost Persuaded', again admittedly a cover, where Rowley comes into her own and finally displays some of the potential we've been force-fed by the Sunday supplements.
Undoubtedly this record will sell decently until the next genuine article is wheeled straight out of Brighton, Bristol or wherever. However, before publicists start harping on about soul, one would advise them to find a pulse in their artists first.
-
I've seen her a few times in Bristol over the years
(having had people rave about her) and this review sums up everything I've ever thought about her music. Thank you.
-
_
If this music would send the 'average listener' to sleep, then surely the record company is making a big mistake in its desperately cynical campaign to appeal to the 'average' audience that you describe.
The fact is that this sort of thing *doesn't* send the average listener to sleep. The 'average' listener will enjoy and buy into this and everyone involved will become very rich and successful. SCUMBAG 'AVERAGE LISTENERS'! SCUMBAG COMPETENT MUSICIANS!
-
the writer
<b>the music.</b> you like it or you don’t. i like it. you don’t. You like Oasis. I don’t. what’s the problem?
<b>the writer.</b> thing i never get about this kind of writing is why people do it. most obviously it would seem motivated by an egocentric drive to feed the feeling of being musically enlightened at a level above most 'average' listeners. to a point when one feels comfortable to take away the value of, and slate, a person’s good work just because you don’t like it. Be a little more creative dom gourlay. Broaden not your taste but you acceptable horizons and relax.
<b>the rabbits.</b> you like long eared rabbits. I don’t. I’m happy with that. -
Bad research Bad 'journalism'.
Unfortunately it seems our wonderful hobby journalist,Dom Gourlay, forgot to open Beth Rowley's CD. If he had he would have found out in the credits on the cd that Duke Special (Voted Irish Male Musician of the year at the Meteor Awards)only sang part of the vocal on ONE of Beths tracks on her album and did not arrange anything. Which makes me wander did Dom even listen to the album? Without that part of the article it just turns into a gush of smug, un-useful personal comment.Maybe he should stick to looking after his bunny rabbits or doing his trade union stuff (fairplay to him) ;) check out his myspace to find out more about his other hobbies: http://www.myspace.com/domgourlay
Don't give up Dom. Just do your research next time.
-
Mortimer/Jamesmattio
I'm actually quite honoured that this review has inspired you both to create new accounts here and therefore contribute to the growing future success of DiS.
However, reviews are meant to be one person's opinion of a record, show or artist. The critique is also meant to represent why said reviewer likes or dislikes said artefact.
As stated in this review, Ms Rowley's and Mr Special's musical competence aren't in question. Their soulless product is, however.
-
...still
Well thats fair enough,if thats you're opinion. It would be better if you did a bit more research thats all I'm saying. Otherwise the review is based on,well,nothing really.
:)
-
Apart from the music that he clearly listened to
which is what a review should be based on -
-
-
-

Comments
Post a new comment on this review