Drowned in Sound Festivals

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


sonic youth kim credit shot2bitz dot net

Don't Look Back 2007

Lineup: Sonic Youth
Date: 30/08/2007
Info: SY play Daydream Nation in its entirety.
no votes
?
by Kev Kharas

On the whole, reunions make me queasy. Returning from London for a month to Maidenhead I knew there would be many - old friends for homecoming drinks, newer ones smoking blunts on the roof of the town hall, acquaintances calling in at mine before a night out with my sisters, lost friends and enemies stalking the streets of town on a Saturday afternoon or a Friday night.

The thought of all make me fizz nervous as I cross the bulgen Thames over Brunel's Sounding Arch, a town pretender come cutting through the smoke to what essentially still is my overgrown village.

"Where've you been tonight?"

To see a record.

"What?"

A record; one I fell first for a girl to.

Not a standard night. A stranded night. A feel of an absence in my cupped hand and in my aching diaphragm.

"You wanker."

The memories...

Daydream Nation is a brilliant, beautiful, tragic record. One of this life's best records, one to dust off and keep in highest regard in the bedroom disc stand or place apart so as not to make it sit in this cheap Argos furniture.

One to put apart because it sets us apart - those who hear it, heard it, cut their losses with mundanity and run. Come cutting through the Sounding Arch smoke but pawing toward a third exit like a train derailed and miraculously skidding upright through a hidden village.

Daydream Nation is a record, a record of a time spent in a hidden zone. A zone that sits somewhere between spine and skull, gurn and flex, tongue bite and nod. It is a chart of Thurston and Kim and Lee and Steve's imaginations; a vessel so in peril yet so sure. Soundtracked by guitars that flit and float and hum like a steel wasp in a rainstorm.

Witnessing this escape. There was a time when the storm still dropped, a captor still loomed, a bullying presence that challenged confidence and made them brave. Now it's a record greeted with darkness and 4,000 clapping hands.

Nothing seems as brave now, in this time. They beat the clocks already, outrun the chase, out thought the schemes, moved faster than speed. That metal wasp flew so far in the rain there was no-one around to sting.

Still, a time outrun but still a turtle time that ticked on in earnest. Arms, hands, fists caught up. Now cod liver elbows are casting shadows on the Roundhouse and giving old, weaker ones the jump.

I'm one of the youngest here tonight.

"You're practically infant school."

Yer. But I still know the beat. The rhythm that taps on pulses and pumps in veins, echoes in chambers and in action leaks out bare. I know what time is, I know a challenge and risk and reward 'cause I know of the warrant that rests at the end of moments, the great validator in its black ceremonial cloak.

"Shut the fuck up."

I digress...

"This nagging voice..."

Crossing and uncrossing arms.

"This brass schema that nags..."

Is this worthwhile? Yeah, Daydream's an escape. How much can a clock puncture its bubble and cede that escape?

Enough. Time is an alarm rousing it and me from sleep.

At least it's not the Stones. They're caught, caged and sorted. This - this will never give altogether. This distortion will blaze not fade. And newness will leak out in between verse / bridge / chorus in feedback leaking like new senses through the gaps in three monkeys.

Brass? Suspension of belief. How much was this 'of its time'? How much of the past is keeping Daydream alive? Is it solid enough to have components? Can you measure it?

Nowhere near. Blink and its gone so - new navigation through new eyes. Zone out, run and beat.

These words? Work it through; start to finish. You can... all's in order. Track it, expected.

"Routine..."

Nagging again...

"Workout...

...A whining voice...

"For a...

...teenage hero?

"Past."

Kick it! I last this long, 'til Kim says and I do, knowing that in 30 seconds I can expect that suspension of belief to break.

"It's 1963..."

"It's 1977..."

"It's 2006."

Snap.

Out the doors, out into it. I loved things the way they were too much to make them normal.

And so, "Joni", now we should really stop the clocks.

Photograph by shot2bits.net

Post a new comment on this review

ooookay


erm

anyone willing to translate?


WTF?

Has he gone loopy?


hmm...

nope, no idea.


some of the most pretentious shit I've ever read on this site

not at all the fact that I'm really looking forward to this gig and want it to be good. More the fact that he has given it a very low market and hasn't managed to coherently justify or explain why it was a '3/10' gig.

Go back to school - you'll never get to write for Pitchfork.


Comments like this are silly.

I like this review.
Tells me EXACTLY what I want to know about the experience.
Also: who'd want to write for Pitchfork? They use 'z's where their 's's should be.


fair enough if you think I'm being silly

but I'll say this: a lot for people are going to these gigs and have been looking forward to them for a while. Therefore, it's fair to assume that people would be interested in the review.

The review says little to nothing about the gig itself, instead it whimsically makes suggestions about the writer's own memories of the album (I think). Also, there is very little correlation between the content of the review and the given score (3/10). He could have probably written the same thing and given it 9/10.

Fair play to the guy - he can write what he wants; but I don't think, within such a context, you can really complain if others find it a little indulgent.


a writer is a person

a life is a context.
a band could be, could save, could make your life.
to neglect the individual, watching and reacting to music, especially at gigs, is to neglect the idea of music being the ultimate communicative artform, the most deep into your veins and existence form of creation and expression.
i liked this review.


I agree with all of that

apart from your final line.

I don't see the individual in this review. There's no real, genuine response to music in this review. Live music can be the purest of all communicative artistic experiences; more than reading a novel, watching a film or seeing a play. Describing the experience of live music should be more than self-consciously recounting obscure allusions and 'memories' - it should be about aspiring towards substance and truth.

But if you genuinely like this review then good shit. I'm not one to challenge someone else's experience of something, but there's some incredible and inspiring critical music writing (some of which is on this site) out there. This is just embarrassing in my opinion.


That's strange,

it tells me NOTHING I want to know about the experience. Normally he's a really good writer as well.


ConcentrationFace...

you know the score...this is the worst bag of shite review i've ever read, i was under the impression a live music review would refer to the music. i guess was wrong.


?

isn't it funny how the people who liked this review were the ones who weren't there


BUT

I've seen them do DN before they brought it to London.
And I didn't like it.
Motions, going through.
Thurston looked like he'd rather be anywhere else.
BUT, wasn't at this show, so.


Sorry but... fuck

I can't agree with or understand this either... not gonna write anything more than that

this piece is making me question my friendship with you... we will speak. later.


Sorry but... fuck pt2

did you stay for the two encores? hmmmm

i don't get the tenuous link between reunions and this gig - what point have SY reformed for this gig?

i think you went with this opinion and let it cloud your judgment


wtf ?

that may be the most head-up-the-arse review i've ever read.


...

So.. er.. was it any good?


but..

..the whole first paragraph goes on about reunions, it may have escaped his attention but Sonic Youth never broke up, they never dissapeared. This is not a reunion.

that just makes the whole review irrelevant really.


A review of a review...

Is it worth reading? Re-reading?

"You don't get it. You're too dry."

A feeling of nausia in my eyes.

"Press back. Try again."

Intimidating words. Spoken order out of.

3/10.


...

is this yr persona for review criticism?

good review


One for Pseud's Corner

I think. Good on you for trying something different though.


Was he even at the gig?

Nothing in this review seems to suggest he was. It mentions absolutely nothing about the performance or the music, just his own memories.
Nothing against trying something different, but you are writing a music review. Perhaps mention the music at some point?


Blah blah blah

blah blah blah Carass should be brought out and blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah ten out of ten blah blah blah. Yip. Blah blah blah blah blah...


KEV KHARAS TALKS SHIT

Kev Kharas - you are some sort of retard - were you even at the show -if you gave that 3 out of 10 -you need help. I bet you like Keane and music like that and things like Daydream Nation probably bypass your tiny brain.


wow, youre a fucking dumbass arent you

i quite liked it cos it read nicely.
Reviews dont all have to be the same old thing each time.


shit review

he doesnt even mention what the gig was like so i am not a dumbass edtsf - if you enjoyed this as a nice read - you must be as pretentious as the writer or just a twat.


cock and balls

this review is fuckin bullshit - fuck off back to bloc party land you fucking nme scum fucknut, i thought shit was supposed to come out of your arse not your cock!!!! another piece of cutting edge journalism from DIS, where the fuck do you find these used cum rag journos?


I liked the review, as a piece of writing.

But I can't really agree with the rating. For me, this show was not a 3 out of 10 experience.
This was worth travelling up to London for, diminishing the heaviness of my wallet.
This show was worth spending a whole night on my own for.
The moment when the second intro riff to 'Cross The Breeze kicked in I nearly fainted with contentment and pulsating joy.
This show was worth going to bed at 3am for.
This show was not a 3 out of 10. Not in my damned book.


Reaidng above I think people have somewhat missed the point here

This is a review of what HE thought- nothing else. And it's very good. I migth not agree with it, but I think it's deserving of a bit of accolade.


Yeah.

I didn't miss the point.
It's a very good review.
But I think you're missing the point. DiS allows us to comment on this review. And maybe give OUR opinion. Which a lot of people are doing.
It IS a good review. I love the review. No qualms about the review.


kev

I saw this lot last night.
the best gig in my entire life.
I was transfixed...sorry you weren't.


this is a load of shite

a perfect example of when a music reviewer forgets their purpose. Either go write a novel or whatever or serve the readership and inform or convey your opinion about something. This is just silly. And usually you write decent straight-forward reviews (not that Im saying creativity in writing shouldnt be there)

The only points you seem to be trying to make are either incorrect (reuinion? eh?) or badly explained (you dont like the nostalgia thing? ok. but why?)


^


what a load of

pretentious art-wank. if it was an article it would be okay, but for a review you are abusing the guestlist place i'm sure you got for reviewing this! people need to relate to reviews, surely the point is to educate?


I really couldn't be arsed by the review when...

1. I saw the format.
2. You gave the gig 3/10
3. You started talking about 'reunions'
Sonic Youth have been churning out shit albums consistently for time. Where was the reunion?

And anyway, the performance on Saturday was flawless and the crowd amazing. I wouldn't want to have changed a single moment of it.


Ok, I just read it...

Utter gibberish.


Thurston Moore would doubtless approve.

I saw Saturday's gig.

It was immense.


Kev Kharas can suck my big fat cock

is this Kev kharas, another of these 14 year old geeky net anus's, with a dodgy £2.50 indie haircut and plan b under sticking out of his arse hole - trying to be clever on his dad's fuckin home computer, getting into shows free then rocking the world with his wit less, point less - reviews. come on for fucks sake DIS, sack this serial rapist. was he on day release from the downs syndrome academy when he wrote this piece?

i was just thinking now that he may have been sexually abused as a boy by a hairy catholic priest? if he wasn't then he deserves to be...


"Kev Kharas: Serial Rapist"

could be the greatest kids' TV show EVER.


well....

... at least the review generated a bit of debate/hatred.

These comments are some of the most amusing bits of a content i've seen on here for a while.

Whip it up Kevvy ma boy.


I was there

on Thursday, it was my 28th birthday and my girlfriend bought me a ticket as a present.

I thought they were fucking excellent, never a 3/10.

That is all.


this is funny...

that is all.


this review

is so much better then my review was of the primavera gig.

as to whether Daydream Nation is "better" live then on record or not depends on your relationship with music. is it a fixed artifact, a single interpretaion, a squence of 1's and 0's or an moment, and event, each different and of it's time and place.

a historical persepctive says it's the later, that our relationship with it is based more on memory and feeling then on any objective facts (of right or wrong). that latter interpretaion comes with age and experience (for me in any case, that there is no truth, but many truths), and not something which sits comfortably with the deterministic world we live in.


tripe.

I didn't actually think this place could get anymore pretentious. I was wrong.


don't worry

we've hardly started. the crack DiS technical team are actually working on a program which will ban any word with less then three syllables.


i think you mean 'fewer'

not less.

and the above article is so pretentious yet at the same time contains so many basic grammatical errors (possessive its, anyone?) that it merely serves to highlight what a self-regarding, vacuous piece of nonsense it really is.

rubbish. the gig, on the other hand, was sensational.


Um, I could be wrong...

...but isn't the reunion talk in the review about a reunion between the memories of the record the first time round and the experience of seeing it live, rather than of the band per se?

And isn't the issue here about indulging in nostalgia, rather than seeing something new?

Hell, but I wasn't there, and I know nothing. And 'stop the clocks'? Jeez.


Sonic Youth

I saw the Saturday show with a mate of mine and we came out grinning from ear to ear.

Then we proceeded to have quite an in-depth conversation about how invigorating it is to see a band who actually appear to have some brains, and how they show up so many other bands as chart-chasers, and how even though their more recent material seems to show some signs of their mellowing with age, they still sound infinitely more experimental than much of what is around at the moment. Yes the show was, to a certain extent, about nostalgia, but there was also a lot of real excitement in the music and the audience.

This conversation then wandered into rather more esoteric territory that I won't bore you with.

That there is still a band around who can still prompt an intelligent conversation and equally inspire mad pogo-ing is a joy.

Once they’d played Daydream Nation and had then come back for another shorter set, I was having a little dream. It went like this: click, click, click, click, “aaaaaarrrrrrrrrgggggghhh…” and then they would launch into Death Valley 69. Sadly that didn’t happen but the gig was a blast anyway.

My personal favourites: Hey Joni and Eric's Trip. Loved it.

Mooseandhobbes


ha! yes

plan B - my thoughts exactly


And that, kids

is why you shouldn't take drugs...


Roller skating Daydream Nation jam called saturday

Couldn't agree more, Saturday was amazing, they were totally into it, like a couple of twenty year olds ! Hey Joni was fierce as you like, maybe this reviewer has had an arguement with his missus..

For a proper review of Sonic Youth head to.. www.beatrwtz.com


Friday was a 9 out of 10

at least!

I saw them once in the 80s and it was a similar energy coming from the stage. What some might find as going through the motions translated more as concentration and to some extent introspection to me.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Glastonbury: three DiSsers, some booze and hella mud...