Drowned in Sound

Search



Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

no votes
?
by Tommy Mack
Damon Minchella, bassist in Ocean Colour Scene has left the band after fourteen years.

However, what makes this remotely interesting is the news that his replacement, at the stinking great crud-fest that the band's Cardiff Millennium Stadium support date with Feeder and Stereophonics undoubtedly promises to be, will be Gary Mountfield.

Mani.

That's Mani, bassist from insurrectionary genre-hopping sleaze-rockers Primal Scream. Mani from messianic jangle-swagger indie-Gods, them Stone Roses.

Mani, it can only be assumed, is being sent on some sort of aversion theraphy by Gillespie and the others, in case he gets slack and does something like Second Coming again.

Why else would an ice-cool genius, the backbone of two of the greatest bands of all time be moonlighting with Ocean Colour Scene?

The suggested reason for his departure is that Damon wants to concentrate on being a Dad rather than a Dadrockstar, and presumably feels that he has achieved all he can with OCS.

DiScuss: Is Mani off his rocker? Does wearing some ropey sweater from Merc make you a mod these days, then? Are you going to the gig? Why?


Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Hmmm. No music weekly cliche opinions cut and pasted into this article then.

Didn't you hear - the NME have dropped their sanctions against The Second Coming now, it's ok and cool to like it, and appreciate the album for the majesty that it is.


Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Bugger...doesn't look like I'll be getting that Virtual festivals job then...

About half of Second Coming is pretty decent, I grant you, but about half is utter wank.

Much as you can admire OCS's sustained popularity through gruelling touring in the face of media disinterest, they are kinda crap, though they probably don't deserve their fate as Dad rock whipping boys for lazy music journos. I, however, was just bamboozled that an impeccable chap like Mani should leap at the chance to play with a band whose output has been patchy at best, some agreeable pub-boogie, but a lot of dreary dross...

Why do people who claim to hate the NME always reference it? I couldn't tell you what the NME's opinion on Second Coming or any other album is, coz I never buy it any more, coz they never put any artists who particularly interest me on the cover. Just. Say. No. It's that simple...

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Au contraire, I think you write very well (Canterbury Fayre) and argue with eloquence and passion which is exactly what we like at VF.

I've just always had a bee in my bonnet about The Second Coming, cos I've just always believed it's one of the best rock albums of all time. But then again I love Led Zeppelin and Guns N' Roses a lot more than The Smiths. I guess it just makes me feel old! (I'm 28)

I agree about OCS tho. They had potential to be semi-decent but always blew it.

I didn't claim to hate the NME. I don't claim to like it, either. In fact, I can't see that it has any relevance to anything beyond functioning as an arduous cattle market for bass players and keyboardists (which is all I use it for).

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

I think the Second Coming thing has something to do with Mister Jenner's songs. You like the Driving South riff, don't you?

The Second Coming is a laborous, laborous album.

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

And you are a laborious, laborious, laborious man Mr. "I'm not big but I AM clever" Teacher.

"Leave them kids alone!"

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Be careful whom you mock...

Since writing this article I've been humming 'The Day We Caught The Train' incessantly.

This frightning lapse into nostalgia came to a head when I found myself playing the Riverboat Song riff over and over again on my guitar and even trying to figure out the widdly bit at the end.

Time for some Trout Mask Replica methinks...

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

There goes his cred, suppose the cash will come in handy for crimbo though.

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

The Second Coming is majestic. But Mani is clearly mad. He's surely not going to join them permanently....?

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

There's no acounting for taste. Let's not forget his Fools Gold-era ponytail.

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

This doesn't mean he's leaving the scream does it?
I'm going to see them on the tour it won't be the same without him

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!


C'mon, parts of the Second Coming are fantastic. I'd take Begging You over House of Jealous Lovers anyday. Obviously Mani's just gone crazy.

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

maybe Mani is hatching a plot to sabotage from within - he is going to strap dynamite to his body and blow up three of the worst bands in the world... Thus ensuring himself a place higher than Kurt and Elvis in the Rock & Roll Martyrdom hall of fame...

ps Second Coming was monkey jism

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

i agree, second coming is patchy but great in places - begging you, tears...
but surely this isn't permanent??!??! I'm finally seeing the scream for the first time in january - he'd better be there! it was undoubtedly mani's bass and kevin shields' amazing guitar that made xtrmntr one of truly great albums in recent years.

Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Hey fuck u guys! Ocean colour scene r the greatest band 2 walk the planet. Any half decent band doesn't aspire 2 being stupid pop acts that only want to be in the fuckin pop charts!! The pop charts are the incarnation of a corporate whore. 90% of the music in the pop charts doesn't sell because its good, it sells because 10 year old girls and boys fuckin drool of the likes of Girls a-fuckin-loud and Westlife!! Ocean colour scene produce some of the most honest, down to earth rock/indie music the world will ever see. They don't sell because of any chiselled jawed or mini skirt wearing image, they aim to please their fans solely on their MUSIC, like bands should do. Money and image are gonna be and r eventuslly leading to the sole downfall of a once respectable Music industry. Sure, the Stone Roses and Primal Scream were pretty cool bands, the stone roses especially. But they aint a patch on the song writing and musical genius of OCS. I'm gutted that Damon left, but he's gotta follow his heart and that's what hes done. I can't believe some people, they don't even recognise the calibur of bands like the scene, the doors, Pink Floyd, the Who, the beatles and so many others. They do it for the music and not the love of some spotty 12 year old "teeny bopper" kid.

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

THe guy's gotta point.

Re: Primal Scene: Mani joins OCS!

Cheers mate, glad someone can see sense.




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - We're here!