e.g., q magazine's 5-star review of razorlight's second album which claimed it was the greatest guitar record since definitely maybe, or something to that effect. incidentally they also gave coldplay's x and y the 5-star verdict, but in their review of vida la vida they dismissed the same album as a misfire..gotta love them!
Try reading
the Observer Music Monthly. It's a rag. They don't appear to bother reviewing stuff they don't already like. Seriously. Everything gets 3 stars or better. Even the fucking Scarlett Johanson album got 4 stars. Wankers.
^ i always say this and nobody believes me.
Thank you, fellow believer
^^^I am with you medulla and 80's kid.
As much as I like the observer the music monthly only gives good reviews.
What the fuck?
I blame
Paul Morley.
Have you read the word-guffs that are passed off as journalism?
Christ.
Hey, what are you complaining about.
Where else do you getto find out Les Dennis's music tastes?
Fuck Les Dennis
You have a lot of anger.
Maybe watching some Family Fortunes repeats would cheer you up?
I have a lot of anger.
Maybe beating the shit out of you would cheer me up?
If it helps sweetheart.
If it helps.
You give me the horn
Sort of sounds like
Rolling Stone
Observer Music Monthly
gives everything 4 or 5 stars, then tells you you can buy it from their album hotline for £12.99. Thats why they say everythings godd, because its good for their business.
*good
I'm losing faith
in the Guardian / Observer. Good for arts (except the OMM obviously) but complete shit for news. And their sub-editors either need to be taught how to sub-edit or given the fucking sack.
Really?
I think it's the opposite. I'll read the news, international news, comment & debate, g2 etc and get a lot out of it. Five minutes with the OMM or fucking Film&Music and I'm ready to kill the fucking lot of 'em.
Mornington Crescent by My Life Story
Didn't the Select review simply say something along the lines of:
"Did you know that this is the worst album of all time?"
Lovely stuff
You should've seen
the one for Golden Mile. 'Badly sung, badly played, badly produced, badly written...' and they gave it no stars.
The Melody Maker one for Golden Mile was brilliant.
Headlined 'Golden shower', and gave it a proper slating.
Quite rightly though, in my opinion.
This by a fucking mile....
www.drownedinsound.com/articles/1412887
That review is overly moist and affectionate
I remember LOLing a lot when that was on the front page...
hahahahahahahaha
big girls bra
heehee
http://i13.photobucket.com/albums/a269/ehwhat/there.jpg
lmao ^^
you made my morning!
Oh god worst start to a review ever
"The first time I heard YS, I cried"
Worst second sentence ever?
"They weren’t just any kind of tears; they felt like conjoining dew drips, the kind you cry when someone touches you so slowly and softly you barely notice ‘til their hand begins to warm your inner thigh."
'...15-minute string-gasm'
:D
i stopped reading it after that, i was laughing too much.
Its truly dreadful, but what about your response to it further down?
"Its true, though."
:( WHY, YES?
oh that is sickening
hahaha
why isn't that posted more often?
I can't bring myself to read this.
...
http://tinyurl.com/5pfu8v
i remember
seeing a review of "and who shall go to the ball, and what shall go to the ball" by scott walker in nme that said that walker has been rubbish since Scott 3 and the only reason anyone listens to him is in the hope he will relive the glory days.
this was not that long before Last Shadow Puppets was announced.
I don't think they quite get it.
by the way
they gave it something stupid like 2 out of 10
Be Here Now pwns this thread
good call.
i remember every major publication was givin it 9 or even 10 out of 10..before eventually realising it was a load of cock
My old band manager
told me about his group, The Pooh Sticks, being reveiwed in a New York magazine.
The review just read "Pooh sandwich."
The Pooh Sticks?
I Know Someone Who Knows Someone Who Knows Alan McGee Quite Well? That Pooh Sticks?
Yes indeed
The Pooh Sticks rule!!!!
(although I was more of a Chesterfields man)
Total rip off of Spinal Tap
Album: Shark Sandwich
Review: "Shit sandwich"
Um
Isn't that the point?
Probably
Just not as funny the second time around.
True dat
The initial critical response to 'Be Here Now' is Why You Should Never Listen To Journos, kids.
It's really, really hard to find any of those reviews online now. Surprisingly enough.
None of them have ever made an attempt to explain it either
beyond some murmurings about all the waivers they had to sign before hearing it. Morning Glory got a lot of lukewarm mediocre two star-style reviews, so it may be the publications were trying to make up for it
this:
http://www.drownedinsound.com/release/view/3039
by a country mile.
'"I return but don’t remain, I’m impatient for a reason
To complain about winter, making me see through again"
They spread their beauty like the best jam, made from boiled up stars and silver moonlight, caught from a reflection using a green fishing net. My pulse begins to gain pace, as my eyes roll into the back of head. I want to eat all the words laid out infront of me. Have them sink into my stomach and turn my blue blood crimson.
Each song is sublime, lyrically and musically. Roddy spills his vocals like a clumsey, just woke up person spilling gasoline. My body taps and jars, i want to jump against walls and hide under my bed, both at the same time. (I mean that in good way)'
Oh god that's terrible
"Roddy spills his vocals like a clumsey, just woke up person spilling gasoline"
BACK TO SIMILIE SCHOOL FOR YOU
it's just terribly embarrassing, really
'Idlewild bend into my ears like a startled cat jumping through a forgotten window. Nothing so stunning has come through that window in so long, I had forgoten it was open.'
LOL! The posts are the end are even funnier.
*posts at the end
mm-hmm
I know you just said this, but it bears repeating
"Idlewild bend into my ears like a startled cat jumping through a forgotten window."
lolmaster5000
I liked that dude
who thought everything was rasist on sone website, there was a thread about it and everything. He thought Flight of the Concords were rasist, he thought Animal Colective were rasist hehehe
PItchfork's Kid A
http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/record_review/21226-radiohead-kid-a
The review is so over the top. I sincerely hope they were being sarcastic.
haha
everything bad about pitchfork summed up in one piece
I'd never read that review, even though I've heard of its reputation
If anything, the Something Awful pisstake is MORE restrained.
classic;
The Italians surrounding me held their breath in communion (save for the drunken few shouting "Criep!")
at least they recognised it was awesome
more than DiS did, the review of Kid A on here got 4/10 or something stupid. it got removed and a message was put up saying that an review that expresses the views of normal human beings will be put up shortly (or something along those lines).
...
The experience and emotions tied to listening to Kid A are like witnessing the stillborn birth of a child while simultaneously having the opportunity to see her play in the afterlife on Imax. It's an album of sparking paradox. It's cacophonous yet tranquil, experimental yet familiar, foreign yet womb-like, spacious yet visceral, textured yet vaporous, awakening yet dreamlike, infinite yet 48 minutes. It will cleanse your brain of those little crustaceans of worries and inferior albums clinging inside the fold of your gray matter.
i can't remember where this was, but...
artist: gabriel
' fuck off, you hook-nosed gremlin'
0/10
A Melody Maker review of Daphne and Celeste
in which they said it was like watching Satan wank onto a dirty tile and being forced up close to watch his spunk travel down alongthe grout picking up dirt as it goes
George Michael - Listen Without Prejudice
"Listen without speakers"
^ good.
NME's review
of The Vines at Reading 2003 was the most hilariously OTT thing I've ever read - it was by one of their last remaining decent journalists to jump ship and head off to the broadsheets where they could write what they liked (possibly Sian Pattenden, but I could be wrong). I don't recall the exact wording, but the review read more like an eyewitness account of the last supper; it was clearly the last "fuck you" of a good writer who'd been told what to think by soulless wankers one too many times and remains possibly my favourite thing I've ever read in NME.
I'll always be fond of this, for more personal reasons:
http://ishotthedeputy.com/node/535
"Presumably the artist went to some trouble to record these tracks. Why he bothered is a mystery - perhaps he is deranged or slightly ill."
Lovely stuff.
Why does the reviewer
make a point of reviewing as many records that you're involved with as possible, purely to slate the fuck out of them?
Besides, if it sounds like anything's stuck in your throat when you sing, it's a Malteser, not a muffin.
It's well cliche
but it just has to be this:
http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/record_review/38853-shine-on
lmao every time
yeah totally. gotta be that.
theres a reason the obvious things are obvious. cause there the best.
Ha ha
I was just on my way to pitchfork to post this link.
Melody Maker's review of Kid A
http://www.followmearound.com/presscuttings.php?year=2000&cutting=85
I imagine some people will agree with the review, but I thought it was pretty funny.
I also remember Q giving Chemistry by Semisonic 5 stars.
Semisonic.
Beaumont was usually right
but he's never been MORE RIGHT than on that Radiohead review. A lone voice in the critical wilderness maybe - but I'm with him.
admittedly i have no experience of mark beamount writing for melody maker
but for fucks sake, he gave hard-fi's debut album 9 out of 10. usually right?
i found him incredibly annoying when i read nme and probably one of the primary reasons i stopped.
unfortunately
Beaumont is a moron. worse, still, he is a moron who thinks he can write. and whats worse than that is, he thinks he's funny. he's not funny. peter cook was funny. I can only imagine the air of giddy self satisfaction as he 'composed' such timeless one liners as 'It is the sound of Thom Yorke ramming his head firmly up his own arse, hearing the rumblings of his intestinal wind and deciding to share it with the world.' peter cook would not have written that. people like him should not be allowed write. he thinks 'deadpan' is a verb. its not a verb. he should be strung up. smug cunt
^This, completely
groop dogdrill
i remember wehn Swells reviews groop dogdrills album for the NME back in the day, it was awarded 10/10 and featured the line ' shag the ceiling till the plaster cracks '
^ and he was right
can't beat a bit of Dogdrill or Beachbuggy... Big up the Doncaster garagepunk scene.
Audio Bullys, Generation (guardian) 1 star
http://arts.guardian.co.uk/filmandmusic/story/0,,1607745,00.html
"Listening to it is like sitting on the top deck of a crowded night bus while somebody flicks chips at the back of your head."
"Simon Franks, who raps like a man concussed ..... Skinner turns prose into poetry; Franks would probably beat up poetry for looking at him funny."
Also see Alexis Petredis' review of the pigeon detectives. Both are fish in a barrel stuff but are still funny.
I love that Pigeon Detectives review
"Emergency seems needlessly cruel, like reading out the menu from Alain Ducasse's Plaza Athénée restaurant to someone eating a Ginster's Scotch Egg Bar."
The Darkness
towards the end of their 'career':
http://www.nme.com/reviews/the-darkness/7858
This
http://www.somethingawful.com/d/your-band-sucks/the-mars-volta.php
Without a doubt.
...
"Thank you for that, Mars Volta, you’ve won me over with your “textures” and your “structures.” You know what else has textures? An iguana, and those motherfuckers will whip the shit out of you with their tails. And you know what else has structure? A nazi death camp, you anti-semites. Okay, I’m rambling because I’m bored. Did I mention this song is thirteen minutes long?"
:-D
yes
agreed.
one read of dr david and all are hooked.
This...
http://www.musicomh.com/albums/weezer.htm
this
http://www.citypaper.com/arts/review.asp?rid=11175
'the pair know how to handle spitting on organs'!?!
WTF?
"regularly beating off the competition"
hurhurhur
"he'll still bend over backward for a hot line"
sniggersnigger
I still love
the Pitchfork review of the Daft Punk remix album Daft Club. Cracks me up.
As for unintentionally funny, Pitchfork's review of Kid A (and that's coming from someone who loves the album).
I always liked this review:
http://www.stylusmagazine.com/reviews/placebo/meds.htm