Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)

80's American Alternative vs 80's british Alternative!

Was thinking about which i prefer and was more influential.

American- The Pixies, Sonic Youth, Husker Du,

Vs

British- The cure, The smiths, Joy Division (sort of),

cant decide!



  • Both

    excellent. I'd probably go for British but I wouldn't fight over it.

    • i think im inchin towards american...

      mainly due to the pixies

  • American by a country mile

    Yes we had Gang of Four and Wire and PiL but nothing came close to that triptyche of Mission of Burma, Minutemen and Husker Du.

    • nothing came close except

      gang of 4, wire and PiL?

  • Why choose the goths to rep the UK though?

    You're on to a loser from the start with that miserable lot.

    What about Half Man Half Biscuit, The Fall, PWEI, The Pastels, Wedding Present, Felt, House of Love, Sundays, J&MC, Primal Scream, June Brides etc etc

    • And

      World Domination Enterprises, ACR, Death in June, a whole slew of United Dairy bands, even Killing Joke.

  • American

    every. single. time

    Sonic Youth, Husker Du, Minutemen, Dinosaur Jr etc etc etc

    • The Wedding Present

      Jesus & Mary Chain
      My Bloody Valentine

      • Don't forget...

        Fugazi...

        • Yeah

          American all the time. Although I love 80s US indie rock so I would say that. Also the Replacements, Descendents, early REM, Meat Puppets. Its no contest really.