Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)
Drowned in Sound

So basically mean not your obvious choices, so no Office, Alan Partridge, Fawlty Towers, Spaced.
Most obscure offering wins a box set of My Two Dads.

5.Nightingales
4. May to December
3. Mulberry
2. Blossom
1. Waiting For God

bumlord | 12 Jun '08, 14:47 | Send note | Report this | Reply



does keeping up appearances count?

sheer genius

Not a sit-com

Not second tier.

VERY, VERY NAUGHTY!

It was comedy

derived by situations.

What more do you need? What would you class it as?

It's not second tier in Standard, just general populus awareness. Jesus, it was cancelled before it had even aired all the episodes, at least three episodes didnt make it on air.

Would you consider

Minder a sit-com?

I accept your second-tier apology.

It was a sit com or comedy show

like
Weeds
UnDeclared

What would you classify 'Ideal' as? I love that show

Drab British sit-com.

I consider F&G to be a drama. Funny but a drama.

It matters not how it is pigeon-holed (despite my previous fury), what does matter is that it is excellent and whoever cancelled it should be made to feel moderate pain.

But it spawned so much

Undeclared
Jason Segel's Career (Forgetting Sarah Marshall written by him, Marshall Erickson in How I Met Your Mother) and i love me a bit of Jason Segel.

Judd Apatows career....giving us such delights at *cough* Superbad, Knocked Up, 40 Year Old Virgin, Anchorman,

Seth Rogen

who wrote for the Ali G Show and UnDeclared and wrote Superbad

I am doomed to watch

all output relating to F&Gs. It has been getting worse and worse. Sarah Marshall was an extreme low - I have seen people praising it on these boards which frankly, is fucking outrageous.

I havent seen it yes

But I LOVE Jason Segel.

...

5.Butterflies
4.The High Life
3. As Time goes by
2. Life goes on
1. Mork and Mindy

Keeping Up Appearances

What class based hilarity

Fuck, just remembered another good one

Chalk

I remember loving it at the time, and lo and behold, it was written by Stephen Moffat. Is there anything this man cannot do?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chalk_(TV_series)

Yeah

so that link didn't paste properly.

.

5. 2.4 Children
4. You Rang M'Lord
3. Waiting for God o/\o
2. The Brittas Empire
1. Hi Di Hi

Oh wait

is Hi Di Hi first tier? Surely not. It had Su Pollard in it.

It was pretty goddamn

mainstream at the time though.

OM fucking G

i used to love the brittas empire!

MISTAH BRITT ASS

MISTAH BRIT ASS

THERE'S A RRAT
IN THE POO-OOL

Good call on waiting for God

5. Perfect Strangers
4. All quiet on the preston front
3. Bakersfield PD
2. Boy meets world
1. Hermans Head

The Fall & Rise of Reggie Perrin had better not count as second tier

but if it does then that would be the easy far and away winner as it's the best sit-com ever made.

Then Malcolm in the Middle could arguably be seen as second tier too in which case that'd be an easy second.

I really liked the Residents when I was 18 or so if anyone remembers it?

My fourth choice will be How I Met Your Mother

and 5th place, though I've only seen 3 episodes, Andy Kauffman, PI

Reggie Perrin

and Mitm are no way second tier.

Phew!

I'm pleased to hear that. I'd have been sorry if they were classed as such.

Actually reading through your thread

As time Goes By and 2.4 children would be in this list. Maybe take the Residents and How I Met Your Mother out but leave Andy Kauffman PI in, even though it's ranked lower.

Don't know why it would be otherwise.

Mr Don & Mr George

GET TO FALKIRK

Dream On

8 Simple Rules
Hangin' With Mr Cooper
Two Guys and a Girl
Home Improvement

with a few exceptions, sitcoms are better when they know their place.

8 Simple Rules

Teh blonde looks so different now, boob and nose job have transformed her now she's in 'Big Bang Theory'

Yeah,

still damn fine though. I do wonder where the angry midget one has gone, I can imagine her with a whinier take on My So-Called Life or something. Issues!

where does My Name Is Earl fit into all this?

The Brittas Empire
Red Dwarf
Keeping Up Appearances
The High Life
The Detectives

thanks for asking.

NO NO NO

Scratch the Detectives, replace with

THE THIN BLUE LINE

Job done. Your cock up. My arse.

And The IT Crowd

oh theres too many.

I wouldn't count it as second tier

but if it counts it'd be right up there.

Red Dwarf

soooo isn't a second tier sitcom, it has it's one of the most succesful british sitcoms ever

..

Rising Damp
Young Ones
Sister Sister

I take it

you're being ironic with Sister Sister

it was comedy

but it was probably third tier, you're right.

Hardware

Peter Serafinowicz and Martin Freeman. Gold.

Aww I liked Hardware

I felt sorry for the student they picked on though.

Oh I love Nightingales!!

Altogether now...

"There's nobody here but us chickens."

I claim the My Two Dads

boxset, please.

For Herman's Head?

You might indeed be a winner, I've never heard of it.

I was thinking of Bakersfield PD.

I've never met anyone else who remembers it.

Herman's head was ace. Synopsis (written by someone else):

Herman Brooks is an aspiring writer working as a fact-checker for a magazine publisher. While dealing with life in the big city, his inner thoughts are played out by four characters representing: his intellect, his fear, his sensitivity, and his lust. His "outer world" consists of a trivia-trove of a boss, two female co-workers, one mouse-ish and the other a snobbish social-climbing bombshell, and a best friend whose both a successful writer, a sexist pig, and an all-around fun guy

WINNER

It had Hank Azaria and Yeardley Smith in it.

Let me seee

1. The IT Crowd
2. The Thin Blue Line
3. Just Shoot Me
4. The Brittas Empire
5. 2.4 Children

The War At Home

8 Simple Runs

The War At Home

is going to give u a lot of grief my friend :P