Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


hercules and love affair
Date: 03/06/2008
9 votes
?
by Natalie Shaw

If the album is an intriguing mythological creature, then the live show is, very specifically, a bald-faced, dress-to-impress ‘70s strip joint. Very different experiences, but it can be hoped that both send heads into a tizz and transform even the most stony-faced into a gooey-eyed romantic.

Hercules & Love Affair without Antony Hegarty is, for sure, a strange(r) beast. ‘You Belong’ remains an erotic symphony, though without Hegarty’s echoey background vibrato thing there’s always going to be a void. So on steps Nomi, her towering presence and diva dancing offering a completely new focus. The bassist is a delight too, sliding most stealthily on ‘Blind’ which provides a fitting showcase for Nomi’s rich, mindful tones. It’s stunning live, but the fact is that it isn’t the album version. And that’s a ridiculously circular thing, because if Hegarty was there then there’d be no enigma. Enough pondering about the absentees, for now. When Andrew Butler introduces “Mr Gayboy herself” Kim Ann Foxman, her soft, slightly flat vocals and 12-year-old-boy-at-the-school-disco shuffle fit aptly into a space. But ‘Athene’ verges on the wrong side of torrid; the brass-heavy interludes there and elsewhere are too introverted for the glamour of the live show, too stagnant for the hedonism. I’d bet that it’s the glamour rather than the introversion that’s the problem, the live show lacking subtlety and trying to compensate with overly shrill, misplaced vocals.

That’s the negatives in a nutshell – from deep within an idealist’s psyche. ‘Hercules’ Theme’ is an exception, played out in dreamlike segue form and retaining the recluse-like brute of the album. And more broadly, the way the songs ache within themselves and find the time to establish their stories is entrancing in a way I didn’t think possible.

So with all that, it comes down to some strange crux as to why the whole show hasn’t completely blown me away. It’s thrown me why I’m so confused but from what I can gather it’s because of how incongruous, ecstatic, cold in parts the album is - and stark in comparison, the live show is exertion personified. In more positive news, isolation and unity meet somewhere left of middle and the set is wonderfully structured, with a furtive cover of Blue Oyster Cult’s ‘(Don’t Fear) The Reaper’ thrown in for extra measure. In fact, the whole shebang is almost as brilliant as it could be.

To sum it all up, I’m a confused cynic with preposterous expectations and a misplaced, self-imposed guilt trip.

Post a new comment on this review

This gig in bullet points

* I could barely hear the bass throughout the gig until they played Hercules Theme at the end.
* The sound levels were quite imbalanced.
* Nomi is no Antony.
* Nomi's vocals on Blind sounded cabaret.
* Kim Ann Foxman sung her lines quite out of tune.
* The harmonies between Kim & Nomi were excruciatingly out of tune.
* Hercules Theme was the highlight of the set.
* The crowd were pretty dull, even for a London crowd.
* The Horse Meat DJs were good, but virtually no-one was dancing.
* The bar prices. The bar prices.


Three


^ agreed

I came away with the distinct feeling that if S-Express reformed it would sound like this.
If it were not for Hegarty and the fact that they are on DFA this act would be judged much more strongly that it is.
The show was lacking in verve, and the atmosphere was as flat as Kim Ann's vocals.
I heard heaven was worse on the Thursday too.


I went...

...to see them on Wednesday night, and thought it was bloody great, despite the absence of Hegarty. The band were amazing.

A tip: if in a place with a horrific bar like that, buy a bottle of wine. £ per alcoholic volume it's by far the most economical option.


I'm confused

this was about Heaven yesterday - which gig is it? I thought Tuesday's was great.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Singles Round-up (28/04/08)