On the Nevermind CD Nirvana started or at least made popular the practice of leaving a bloody long gap before the last song. Now they all do it, but is it ever worth the wait? Most times it’s a long wait then a bit of buffoonery or some addition song that’s just filler. I’m asking you, which bands have longest gap between the last song? And who has the best/worst “hidden track” ?
I quite like A Crackup at the Race Riots
by Hope of the States.
Astounding.
my copy of Nevermind didnt have endless nameless at the end
apparently thats quite rare? Was a printing error in the first run of copies i think.
Generally, i dislike 'hidden tracks', basically for not being hidden at all, and messing things up on iTunes!
The good ones are when the silence isnt too long and the track puts on a different spin on the album you just heard. Like at the end of 'Attack of the Grey Lantern' by Mansun, the hidden track just pokes fun at the whole concept album that preceded it.
How about
the hidden track on Attack of the Grey Lantern by Mansun? don't know what its called but the lyrics go 'the lyrics aren't supposed to mean that much, they're just a vehicle for a lovely voice'.....i like that one.
spooky
it clearly is
the best hidden track!
Yeah, good one
It's called An Open Letter To The Lyrical Trainspotter.
I've always wondered
what that song was called. One of my favouritest albums, that is.
Shooting at Unarmed Men
Yes Tinnitus is the album. After the last song, you hear the whole album again speeded up to about 5 or 6 speed. Then you hear the whole album again in normal time. Mental.
That is the precise reason
"In Flight Instructions..." is not on my walkman. It always seems like a new track when I dig the cd out.
The end bit of My Warm Blood
where there's nothing put that low-pitched bell and background noise. That was quite weird, thinking the record had finished and then thinking I was hearing bells.
The other one's Klaxons - Four Horsemen. Nothingness for about 17 minutes then stupid alien noises at the end. That was quite off-putting the first time round.
Subhuman race by Skid Row
The CD 'ended' then a while later I'm looking out the window trying to see who is the tool playing techno really loudly outside, then I realised it was coming out of my speakers. They had finished a metal CD by sneaking on some drum and bass!
Also I was listening to a Jane's addiction CD single really late at night, I was about to draw the curtains and turn it in when a little voice said "goodnight", I jumped out of my carpet slippers!
NIN - Broken
the nine inch nails e.p 'Broken' is a 6 track e.p followed by 92 tracks of 5 seconds of silence, followed by 2 hidden tracks. I reckon thats the biggest gap I know of.
Then both the hidden tracks kick ass so its ok
There's a placebo album with a very cool piano instrumental
about 5 hours after the album's finished. It is probably the best thing on it actually.
Long album= good
I still can't get out of the habit of feeling pleased if a CD is a long one. When it's 20 mins I feel cheated but at the same time the best albums are the shorter ones with no filler. Plus the longer ones have 20 mins of silence anyway...you can't win!
whats that QOTSA album
i think its songs for the deaf (it always seems to be) where if you press back after the first track theres a cool 'hidden track'
I think the latest Brand New album does too.
QOTSA
If you pressed back wouldn't the first song start again?
you have to rewind it
then the hidden track starts.
yeah, say:
if you were on track 2 and wanted to go to track 1. do that but on track 1.
hidden tracks are annoying
if a band thinks it's such a relevant piece of music to include it on the album, then why not just put it on as an 'official' track? or put it as a b-side? or something like that. i think they can take away a certain...i don't know what from an album.
it irritates me when i listen to nirvana when going to bed, put my ipod on shuffle and the first song to come on is 'all apologies' or something. in fact, 'something in the way' is one of my favourite nirvana songs, but it has 0 plays on itunes, because i just skip to the next song instead of waiting 16-odd minutes for the end. or 14 minutes for 'endless, nameless'.
blah blah blah moan moan moan
They
should have fucking considered this whilst making those albums! Cunts!
yeah, complete set of bastards
making me open my eyes to press the 'forward' button. that's easily 4 seconds out of my sleeping time!
I really
don't know HOW you can sleep with music on...I find it impossible.
Is my MP3 player f**ked?
That's what you think when there is a long gap when it's on random. And when it's docked at parties? Forget about it!
I still don't get the QOTSA skipping bit, I blame the clocks going back!
SFA - Citizen's Band
from guerrilla. you need to rewind the cd at the beginning.
The idea is generally pointless
...with a few exceptions. Eels didn't want to put "Mr E's Beautiful Blues" on "Daisies Of The Galaxy", but wrote it after his label said the album had no singles. Normally you'd hate a label for that, but we got one of their best tracks out of it. So I guess it makes sense if the artist has put together a complete "body of work" that they want you to hear, but there's also something else worth having.
If
that makes any sense.