Drowned in Sound

Search



this will destroy you
13 votes
?
by Mike Diver

Relative newcomers on the post-rock block – and yes, that term is a necessary evil here, so best to get it out of the way early doors – This Will Destroy You play out like something of a threat to Explosions In The Sky’s instrumental crown on paper: the foursome (natch) are from Texas (natch), and recorded this with EITS producer John Congleton (natch, thrice). So far, so so what, and fairly: more often than not purely instrumental rock acts suffer from setting written-word rhetorical precedents their output can’t shine a candle to. But this self-titled debut proper really is worthy of investigation beyond a cursory PR scan and the now obligatory Wikipedia scouring.

The follow-up to a collection of demo recordings regarded by some to be the band’s debut, titled Young Mountain, this eponymous offering presents seven tracks of sublimely slow-shifting sound floes; some tracks toe a conventional line in quiet/loud dynamics, traditional in the post-Mogwai landscape, but the initial standouts are performed in a looser, more freeform manner which suggests This Will Destroy You are less concerned with ticking emotional boxes, and more with tempting the listener to explore textures and territories not entirely within their comfort zones. So, we’ve ‘Villa Del Refugio’, seven minutes of drifting drone that ripples like the most engrossingly avant electronica but possesses a divine warmth that ensures only the truly frozen of heart won’t eventually allow to guide them to a level of synapsual arousal rarely encountered.

The quartet’s incorporation of 65daysofstatic-coloured clicks and bleeps on a couple of occasions – most notably the opener ‘A Three-Legged Workhorse’ and the penultimate ‘They Move On Tracks Of Never-Ending Light’ – also sets them aside from the more homogenised post-rock ranks as an act willing to just step out of line enough to be noticed, without becoming an annoyance. These additional beats aren’t blistering like those familiar to the Sheffield act of most convenient reference, though; instead they dance like mechanised insects above a still lake, the heart and soul of the pieces in question – the low sun on the water, the gentle breeze in the warm air – the held notes and sustained, well, moans. Few bands – Mono one immediately apt comparison, and subsequently an exception – can coax such lingering lusciousness from the most basic of elements: two guitars, bass and drums.

But nobody should approach This Will Destroy You anticipating new forms of a type of music that can often have its course plotted ahead of play, for better or worse depending on your personal opinions and tastes, with a decent degree of accuracy. What the inquisitive should expect is exactly the expected, executed with close to perfection precision. Quirks and deviances are here, as noted, but their short supply leaves the largest impression to be made by conventional builds and breakdowns, peaks and higher peaks – tracks like the sumptuous ‘Threads’ and rollercoaster closer ‘Burial On The Presidio Banks’. And the four-piece’s evident mastering of this wordless language ensures that their debut album is a true classic of its kind. EITS, and high-profile peers, take note: relative newcomers they may be, but This Will Destroy You are can’t-fail successors to the crowns that now rest so unsurely on your brows.

  • This Will Destroy You 8 / 10
Words: Mike Diver

This album is much better than I had thought it would be

It adds very little to the genrein terms of experimentation or deviance, but at the same time doesn't sound like a cold cash in. Special props for the so-awful-its-good vinyl artwork too


Basic review

Pretty obvious that you don't listen to that much post-rock/instrumental music, far too many overblown cliches and generalisations used. They really aren't the next big thing in post-rock, it's Caspian who will take EITS crown, and aren't really a new band considering the 'Young Mountain EP' was a pretty big deal.


z z z

I listen to loads of post-rock.
Just ask the office.
They hate me for it.
Tra la la.
mx


The cliches and generalisations are apt

and 'Young Mountain' really wasn't that much of a big deal if you consider it wasn't originally released on Magic Bullet and was essentially just a demo they sold from the back of a van until they were signed


20,000

sold makes it quite a big deal, considering the size of the band, and, as you correctly point out, was mostly self-released. It still got the band a lot of hype and intention in underground cirlces.

Mike, I'm glad you listen to lots of post-rock, maybe their could be a bit more love on the site for Caspian (best post-rock album of the last 5 years), Gifts From Enola, You.May.Die.In.The.Desert, and a whole host of other top notch bands?


Maybe

But we can only cover what we're sent. Review wise anyway.


oh

and I like the album, it's just a bit samey and not overly original. 6.5/10 for me.


its a solid album

it deserves an 8 just for threads.
which is a brilliant song.

and fuck caspian.
gifts from enola is where it's at blates.


WHUT

EITS don't even have the crown. Sigur Ros do, and I don't see anyone taking it off them in the forseeable future...


I think I'm

suffering from Post-Rock Burnout.
I love it, but seriously I've had enough for awhile, I'm gonna go listen to singer/songwriter stuff just for a palette change and I'll come back for these critters later.


i get like that abit..

but then again i prefer instrumental/ambient to lyrics.

quite liked this album anyway, kinda wished they used abit more electronic noises in more of their songs as i think thats something they do so well.


this album

was a massive disapointment to me. Young Mountain showed such promise, (particualrly the epic final song). TWDY's (slightly) aggressive slant offered an appealing post rock choice to the endless supply of dullsome instrumental bands out there.

But they have wasted the opportunity with a really average record. Alot of the songs are way too long and fail to develop into anything other than generic instrumental recordings. The inclusion of processed percussion on one or two tracks is a mild distraction but fails to provide any real diversity to the listening experience.

I agree with steveholts comments that Caspian are the post rock band everyone should be namechecking these days rather than the obvious Mogwai, EITS comparisons. The American website TheSilentBallet.com is the place anyone with a real passion for instrumental should be reading these days. I think DiS mainly caters for 'The Next Big English Bands' these days which is why I've lost alot of interest.


^ This

TheSilentBallet.com is a really good website, I've only started visiting it in the last couple of months but for a specialist music zine it is hard to beat.


Cos so many people know about Caspian...

...they should totally be a benchmark, etc.

z z z


?

It's more about the quality of their album than their rep, earning attention through merit etc.


Sure.

But if you are presenting a new band to new ears, having obvious reference points is more productive than a list of similar-level unknowns.


Agreed

With this being a predominately indie webzine you can't alienate your base, but you could name-check some more obscure artists alongside the likes of EITS for greater reference and exposure. And scene points, don't forget them.

On a side note, was the hilarious 80s artwork only for the vinyl?


the artwork

with the 2 birds of prey? that was class.


yeah...

...the vinyl artwork is amazing.


I would hardly call

Caspian "unknowns"!!!


Exactly

and not writing about them because a majority of your readership hasn't heard of them surely goes against good music journalism, you should want to share new bands with the masses.


talking of Caspian

how come they never tour the UK? They are one of the bands I am most eager to see and ferociously loud by all accounts.


October

according something on The Silent Ballet forum.

Doesn't seem that convincing though, I think they need a label over here, but I'd love to see them.


DiS is an English based site

and TWDY are American. I'm not sure I see your point


Amazon finally delivered this today.

After a few listens, 8/10 seems completely correct. 'The Mighty Rio Grande' is one hell of a song, as is the final one, like you say.

Good review.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - The Weekly DiScussion: who should make the Mercury shortlist?