Drowned in Sound Festivals

Search



'Gay' as a derogatory term

no votes
?
by julian_in_public

what are your opinions on this?
I for one have always argued against people who do it and hate the complete ignorance of it. yet they always try and maintain the fact that they aren't 'doing any harm' (i actually had an argument with Adam Buxton about it over an email cause he said it on his website and i thought he was an intelligent person) anyway, it just always ends up with them still believing they are correct and with me thinking the world has turned upside down when the people you respect are turning into idiots too...

anyway, this videos hammers my point home... http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Mx9VLHYvEJc

what i need is the steel wit of Bill Hicks.... :)

julian_in_public | 27 Nov '07, 15:07 | Send note | Report this | Reply

daddy?

what are you doing in public?


is that

like your default reply to everything? :)


Fine then

no afters for you after tea tonight young lady!


i don't live with you

and haven't done for over five years. you need to get over that. i've gone.


I see your point (Oooh matron! etc)

It seems to me that the use of the word in a derogatory sense had faded away, but, there apppears to have been a major resurgence over the past few years.

Ironic homophobia: the new rock and roll?


I don't care that much really

the fact that the word gay ever came to mean homosexual is in itself evidence of the fluid nature of language, so in that sense it makes no sense to claim it is evidence of homophobia.

On the other hand, the fact that gay has now become a term of derision derives from attitudes to homosexuality...


I shouldn't have used the word

sense so many times. I've lost all grasp of the English language today...


I understand

the whole 'words meanings change over time' thing, but i still think its silly and ignorant to use it for a slag word... i mean it originated with the thick chavs using it where i come from, cause they are genuinely homophobic, but now the people that are supposed to be intelligent and question things (people into good music etc etc) are using it too, so to me it just then makes them seem like idiots too...


Have you ever read 'Down and Out in London and Paris'

Theres a bit in there which discusses what makes an insult, the idea being that any word can be an insult if the intention of the person saying it was to be insulting and vice-versa. Might be applicable here?

I think as far as tackling homophobia and general prejudice goes, the casual use of the word gay in a derogatory sense should be lower on lists of priorities than some more pressing issues


of course

yeah, there are MUCH more important things in the world and iam in no way saying this should be top of the list, but this is something i have around me everyday so it just irritates me a lot.


Johnny Ball

is supposed to be intelligent and he listens to Gay Dad and The Frattellis.


if you use terms like 'thick chavs'

are you really in a position to complain?

i'm sure you'll be able to articulate a difference, but just putting that out there.


I use it

fairly often, just because its a word thats stuck in there, and sound amusingly childish.

Some of my best friends are homosexuals*.

*copywrite Lowri Turner


In 10 or 20 years time

we'll look back and be slightly embarrassed that this was as commonplace as it is

And that's coming from somebody who says it himself


I agree

But its just the principal of it all... i dont understand why people defend the use of it unless they are being irnoic. every time i argue with people abiout it they just claim they arent saying it to offend, so its harmless... but how can that work really?? i mean so if i decide im gonna start calling stuff i dont like 'paki' instead of 'shit' how is that not offensive? how can you defend it seriously?? these people using the word are basically saying, "I dont like something, therefore it is GAY" which means they dont like things that are gay, gay people etc... and thats the end of it...


cont.

if they werent homophobic, they'd chose to use a different word for the insult instead


Yeah it's kind of sad

South Park does it too, although they might try to use the Bernard Manning 'we offend everyone equally excuse'.


yeah

really annoys me when South Park do it, they should be taking the piss out of people who are using the word instead :)


I'm uncomfortable with it.

I'm aware most people who do it aren't being homophoic but the use of the word as a derogatory term stems from attitudes to sexuality and so it doesn't make me comfortable.

I'm also curious to know how many people'd use gay as a derogatory term in the presence of a homosexual who they had not met before? And if they weren't comfortable to use it then but were the rest of the time I'd be interested to know why that was.


I've done this

accidentally when I was at work about 6 years ago. Supervisor was homosexual, asked me to do something, I exclaimed 'gay'. He knew i didn't mean it offensively and sort of laughed. I went red. He wins.


haha

Smooth.


ta

fortunately the guy was a legend. They latter replaced him with someone who also happened to be similarly inclined, but in the obnoxious sneering militantly politically correct mould. He was a knob.

And thats the history of the Safeway Lutterworth Assistant Managers position as known to me.


S.L.A.M.

I wish my job title had dynamic-sounding initials.


oi you dropped your gay card!

god that cracks me up everytime.


at uni without a computer

as i dropped pimms on my old macbook.
got new one now off the government. isn' it just fantaastic news?


i've never been happier

you are my favourite person in the world that has ever existyed ever.


he is one of teh best DiSers yeah

neecho- how did you get a free computer? are you dyslexic? my mate got a mega laptop cuz of that, with printer and scanner and everything.


that's the one!

though i upgraded to a macbook for a nominal fee. it's ridiculous.
i even got a mac keyboard. god knows why. it's needless, i'm not even that dyslexic.
but it IS fantastic.


do you have the OCR scanner which scans your books and stuff

and then reads it back to you!


I used to be uncomfortable with it.

I am now pretty indifferent to it. The perceived homophobia implicit in using "gay" to mean "rubbish" is not even present in 99% of the usages of the term in that sense. I have never met a gay person who was offended by this. The people who are seem to be uptight straightlords. No offence.

i.e. it's REALLY not a big deal.


thank you

for expressing my own views without me needing to articulate them.


"straightlords"

:D


in all seriousness though

i do use it. not as much as i used to but i still use it. i probably shouldn't but i'm quite lazy.


I don't feel uncomfortable

about gay. It's a nice sounding word so I guess it doesn't feel bad or bring around any negativity. I wouldn't feel embarassed saying it in front of a gay person either.

I'm uncomfortable about "fag" though, for sure.


ok

so if 'gay' is a nice word, which yes, it is supposed to be a postive word, (hence homosexuals adopting it form its orignal maening 'happy'), why use it as a negative word then????!!!??


If you're going to be negative

may as well do it in a positive way


you are of course right

but it is low level and thus most people think that you are being 'pcist' rather than 'equalitist'

Since we are trying to convince the ,majority to be tolerant and accepting then it can prove counter productive to be seen as pcist, of course it may not be counter productive too, I may be wrong on this one, I've kind of given up on this and occssionally join in but argue the more important and win ble battles.

You are right though.


ha ha

yeah, i totally agree, i give up a lot of the time too...


The problem is there is no study made of school dynamics and childrens relationships or systems of l

apart from when they do insultingly simple single issue investigations into racial discrimination etc and they segregate this from the mechanisms of peer discrimination and group bonding dynamics all together.

Really, most adults totally shut their eyes to what occurs in school outside of the lessons.


actually yeah

thats exactly what the use of it is.
CHILDISH. children would use the word unaware of the implications or what it truly means... ( as i remember they did in my primary school) becasue they are children. and adults have had 10X the life experience so they should know 10x better..


seems a bit

childish.


in college, when my friends used the term i'd always have a go and say "dont use gay as a derogatory

this ended up turning into a bit of a joke though as the word is now so commonly used that im immune to it. i dont think it is very offensive anymore as there is no meaning behind it.

and yes, i've used it in front of gay people i haven't known before (because its so a part of the vocabulary of the people i hang around with that its just automatic) and gay people have called me it too.


i don't see how it's offensive...

i probably wouldn't say it but i can see why people do. when you say 'that's gay' you don't mean it's homosexual, you mean it's a bit funny, no, as in 'isn't that a bit queer'. To me something being 'gay' or 'queer', generally, and not in the terms of human relationships, but in general language means 'a bit odd'.


well that's the point isn't it

but the word 'queer' MEANS 'odd', it's just been reapproiated by the gay community.

the word 'gay' MEANS 'happy' (originally) so using the term for that is fine, but using it to mean 'odd' or rubbish is the result of thinking gays are odd or rubbish, right? else why would use the word unless you meant 'happy'?


Exactly

you talk sense my friend :) exactly what i said to someone else


surely then...

you've answered your own question?

the word 'queer' was adopted by gay people, so 'gay' and 'queer' being confused is just progression of the english language?


to quote what i said before

if 'gay' is a nice word, which yes, it is supposed to be a postive word, (hence homosexuals adopting it form its orignal maening 'happy'), why use it as a negative word at all?

if thats a progression, its backwards...


Did I have to be here at the time this was posted

for it to make any sense at all?


well

everyone im around uses the word for something they think is really SHIT or something they HATE


i tend to spell it ghey when it's a bad thing

and gay when its about homos!!

but i love gay people, i even have a gay friend, he used to help me chose my wardrobe!!!!!!11"121!!!


cool, i'm glad you like gays too

gays are great aren't they?!?


...

oh yeah, because we all know how gay people are dead good at choosing outfits and interior decorating.


don't like it

shows up people who do it as inferior. ALL INFERIOR LIFE MUST BE DESTROYED!


have you been MIA?

how are you?


the only thing that offends me about gays, generally, is...

the way that to a lot of them, their sexuality is the biggest part of their personality. i actually wouldn't mind going to gay bars more, if a) most of the men weren't reall old & leary, and b) the younger ones weren't so mary poppins. i find straight-acting gays generally quite charming. it's all a bit too promiscuous for me, though, really.


well many hetero builders do this too

leering at women.

At least the mary poppins types have got the legitimate excuse of them just exploring their freedom, they might have had to hide what they truely felt at home or at school (and I dont just mean the acts)
Im straight yet kind of enjoyed my own mary poppinsy moments at polytechnic, it was so nice to not have to conform without being seriously picked on


agree about the leery old men though

(I've felt oppressed and threatened by them myself as a youngster, and I dont think our gym master was even G**


ANYONE

watched the video yet???? its a bit shitily made, but gets the point accross much better than me....

see that kid playing the guitar?? that is what your children will become if you dont stop using the word out of ignorance!


no


the person next to you

could be transgendered. Probably not though. I like the song....


algæ


:D


....

it is wierd. since moving to sheffield where my gf seems to be the hub of the local gay scene (she used to be a nurse) i have become more conscious of how often i say it. i am trying to cut it out.

how come things being "fat" is a bonus? when i was a kid it never felt good to be called "fat". maybe thats why so many kids are fat now. or are they phat?


....

does that make me a straightlord?


heh heh

as long as your are thinking about it, you are going the right way about things


A guy was chatting

to me on saturday night and stopped and said "I'm not chatting you up or anything" I never thought he was in the first place. As for the word 'Gay'- I'm foul of using it as our all of my mates. Must be because we're all chavs or something...yeah.


The Point is

if you dont agree with that that video says, or can see the error of your ways through it, im sorry but you are a very shallow minded person...


Interesting...

Just from a personal point of view. I'm a gayer, it rarely bothers me. I have noticed however that the vast majority of times that "gay" is invoked, it's in attack of something extremely straight.
Your best mate hanging out with his girlfriend instead of coming to the pub, getting drunk and hugging you saying he doesn't say it enough but he loves you is most definitely straight.

I also enjoy when someone says it, then shoots their head back 180 degrees and shoots you a rabbit in headlights looks. Heeheeh.


I use it all the time.

The thing about it is that as a word it has a fantastic denunciatory quality to it. "This is so GAY." Brilliant, never fails.


i agree.

it makes me genuinely angry that people i like do this. mostly because i know of friendships have been ruined by certain parties not realising they were saying 'thats so gay' in a derogatory way every five seconds in front of people who were gay and couldn't face coming out because of it.

people that say 'oh dont take it so seriously' are basically being as idiotic as people who make racist jokes and say 'oh you're so politically correct, we're on having a laugh, some of my best friends are black'... it's not being politically correct, it's being kind enough not to use an important part of many people's lives as a word to describe shit things.

*seeths*


yes

yes yes yes yes yes yes yes again :)
at least someone on here has some common sense :)


I use it

and don't, for a second, associate it with homosexuality.
And anyway, a person's sexuality is supposed to be arbitrary aspect of their character. If someone is acting "gay" then that just means they're being annoying, not that they're being "typically homosexual".
Though I can see why it would annoy people, and I should probably cut down. I watch south park too much.