So much for the ‘tricky second album’. Circa Survive laugh in its face, grabbing the gauntlet with eagerness.
On Letting Go isn’t just a strong follow-up to Juturna, it’s a revelation. It’s easily one of the best albums of the year so far, a sky-scraping realisation of Circa Survive’s talent and intelligence. Beautiful, intense, powerful - this is the sound of emo grown up and old, wisdom accrued.
Radiohead, Muse, Coheed and Cambria, Mew, the Mars Volta - this record blends them all together and emerges as an individual, borrowing bits of prog and delicate indie and cranking up the volume. Former Saosin vocalist Anthony Green screeches high up in the register, set free like never before, stretching for each note as though his life depends on it. He’s too passionate a singer, too fired-up, to be called ‘angelic’, but it’s only the brooding, slashing riffs behind him that keep his voice tethered to the earth.
Circa Survive’s cover art again implies floating through the air, and it’s a perfect visualisation of how you feel when listening to On Letting Go. Swept up into the clouds, racing over landscapes, rocketing up, plunging down, hurled into electrical storms.
Structure is still prevalent, and songs like ‘The Greatest Lie’ and ‘The Difference Between Medicine And Poison Is In The Dose’ start easily and then thunder into squealing choruses - this is the sweetest pop, but with firecrackers attached. The prog influence emerges more in songs like ‘Kicking Your Crosses Down’ - which flits between uncertain, eerie codas - but even here there’s a reassuring melody waiting around the next corner.
If there’s one complaint about On Letting Go, and it’s bloody hard to find one, the shrieking combination of riffs and Green’s voice is utterly unrelenting, which can get tiring and headache-inducing, like a woodpecker bashing at your temples. To that end, On Letting Go could have been trimmed of a song or two, brought down to ten tracks, and still triumphed. But heaven knows which songs would go, because every single one of them warrants repeated listens, secrets crammed into every crevice.
In short, this is a masterpiece.
Alright mate,
it wasn't that good. They're alright when they're on form, but it can get a bit bleh. It's kind of repetitive when they start every song strong, drop it down for the verse, and bring it back up for the chorus.
I like it, but it isn't a masterpiece. The art's ace though.
8 is now "masterpiece"?
You docked them a couple points on the squealing chori, huh?
RsTJ
This shows a weakness in the website
How can 8 be a masterpiece?
That's not very consistent now is it. Pitchfork's rating system is more reliable it must be said.
Oh me.
Oh my.
You hear that, Mike?
He has pinpointed a weakness in the seemingly sheer face of rectitude that is DIS. Oh Jericho, here is thy Joshua.
Bell-end.
Pitch-fork off
I can barely make it to the end of PF's reviews to even find the rating system, which makes it pretty pointless.
At least this review didn't make me wanna drop arsenic into into my Frosties, despite the dodge rating.
Yeah but,
the rating's at the top.
And oh yeah this
is a very good album.
Good point
Well made.
Been a while since I was on there clearly.
Oh
Do people still read Pitchfork then?
this album
is awesome. amazing band.
*Sigh*
To me, yes, an 8/10 is a masterpiece. I don't think I've ever given a nine in my short life thus far. You may quibble, but that's just my way I'm afraid. So, deal.
Barry
Anyway I cant now I have to for a Barry
Did this just come out in the UK?
I've had it ages.
It ain't out in the UK.
Only available on import, yo.
Just like the rest of Equal Vision's output.
If that label and Big Scary Monsters teamed up, it would possibly make the best record label, liek, EVAAAA.
One thing I am
not very happy about this album is that most songs have more conventional choruses and song writing compared with those on Juturna. But that's not necessarily a bad thing though. It just makes listening to this album not that challenging anymore. Have a listen to Carry Us Away, which IMO is the best song Circa have ever created. The mood of that song is perfect.
I am going to go and but this tomorrow...
on the strength of the original.
Cause that was fucking ACE.
xx
yeah
this is really really good.
Eh
"Juturna" is light years ahead of this album. "OLG" is too poppy, structured and produced. It's better than 99% of the stuff in their genre, but their debut will probably always be their masterpiece.