Drowned in Sound

Search



babyshambles blinding ep
no votes
?
by Dom Gourlay
  • Type: Single
  • Release date: 04/12/2006
  • Label: Regal
  • Info: Five-track EP

Right, let's start by making it clear that this review is going to focus on the music and nothing else. Forget the ongoing tabloid soap opera surrounding Pete Doherty and his Gucci-sponsored girlfriend, it's the tunes that count and that's why we're here. Okay? Okay...

...so let's begin.

And to start with, the title track of this five-track EP isn't actually that bad: there is a semblance of rhythm and melody - something that was distinctly lacking in a large proportion of last year's Down In Albion collection - even if you do get the impression that you have heard it somewhere else in another lifetime, like on one of those sixties beat-pop compilations featuring the likes of The Yardbirds and The Spencer Davis Group, for example.

Doherty's vocal sounds more at ease and less-pained here than on previous Babyshambles releases - so far, so good then.

By the same token, it has to be said that the majority of this EP is instantly forgettable, so by the time 'Love You But You're Green' has finished plodding on like a drunken grandad at a funeral, followed by 'I Wish' and its comedy ska jollities (more nauseating than exciting), the next few minutes are spent looking at your watch waiting for the CD to end.

Of course it doesn't, and 'Beg Steal Or Borrow' turns out to be one of the best songs Doherty has recorded under the Babyshambles mantle: it flows along like an insistant swan, chasing after the last morsel of crusty bread that a little kid has just thrown into the Thames.

After that, there's still one more to go, and 'Sedative' is exactly that - comatose and mournful, and best left alone unless insomnia comes biting.

All in all, this would have been an interesting single - two of the songs on it represent a surprisingly buoyant edge to this much-maligned outfit. Sadly, padding 'The Blinding' out to three-times longer than necessary, to an EP, asks too much of the listener. But still, it's better than anyone could possibly have expected.

  • Babyshambles 6 / 10
Words: Dom Gourlay

it being

better than anyone expected, still doesnt make it good though. i've only heard the title track, and it sounds to me like a label saying 'look! he's clean! he's got it together...' etc.

its still shockingly average for someone who showed so much promise once.


Well said

I was expecting a whole bunch of "Pete's a GOD" and "No, Pete's a COMPLETE CUNT AND HIS MUSIC IS THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES".

Actually, I kinda agree with that second statement. Still, balanced comments are where it's at.


Babyshambles

Does anyone elese think the guitar riff for The Blinding sounds like Jimi Hendrixs Foxy Lady?


Now you mention it

I suppose there is a definite similarity.


Great, balanced reviewing!

Lovely to see!


This isn't some knee-jerk reaction to their success (its a bit late for that)

but am I the ONLY person who really just doesn't get all this fuss about these folks?

Libertines were a piss-weak Clash rip off without the charm or wit or indeed tunes

Babyshambles / DPThings are as above, just without the decent record sleeves as well

s.h.i.t.e.


Good song, cool video...

...but doesn't really make me want to go watch it again...well, ok, maybe for the guitar sound...and the lyrics were kinda interesting....ok, maybe I'll go back and check it out again.

Guy's *&#$ing Kate Moss. He must have something going for him besides stellar drug connects.


i'm fed up

arguing with people about pete d. i think babyshambles are a good band. i think pete is a great front man, he writes good songs with excellent lyrics.

i am not surprised that this ep is very good. beg steal or borrow is an excellent song.


Say what you want

about the Libertines but they don't lack tunes. At least not on the first album. Even the second has some songs of note.


I think

libertines/babyshambles/dirty pretty things are all very good bands.

Pete Doherty himself is an excellent musician, and front man.

Hoping there wil be better things to come from him, and possibly even a Liberitnes revivial? I cna only hope


"Pete Doherty himself is an excellent musician, and front man."

That is an INCREDIBLY bold statement.
I think even Mr Doherty would admit he can't play guitar, or sing. All he can do is write decent lyrics sometimes.


Ok

maybe excellent is a bit excessive.

But saying he can't play guitar at all or sing is also a bit upfront.

When he performed beg steal or borrow by himself on Jonathon Ross, it proved that he has got talent.


It was indeed

It may just be me, looking at things from a comparative perspective, but to say Pete Doherty is good at playing guitar because he can strum along to a generic acoustic song is almost farcical.
He's to music what Peter Kay is to comedy. He's not the best at what he does by any stretch of the imagination, but because he sings about the bleeding obvious and being affably british everyone seems to love him.


pete

I actually quite like this EP; I've never been overly impressed with anything pete did post-libs, but I do like this. Sedative is probably my favourite track on it and was surprised to hear them doing a song that wasn't either trashy punk or trashy ska.


Ignorant Misled Idiot Scenester Phony

If you don't like him then why are you even reading all this, let alone posting a comment. I hate all you scenesters who think your opinions are worth a damn. I think there are so many things wrong with your comment that I don't know where to start, well maybe I do, but I just can't be bothered.


I also like

Love You But You're Green. They performed it on The Culture Show and I was pretty impressed. Not a big fan of the ska song on here, but otherwise a huge improvement on Down In Albion.


video on VBS

want to see the BabyShambles Practice Space show? Check it out on VBS: http://www.vbs.tv/player.php?bctid=377215267





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - The Week That Was - The Week That Was