Drowned in Sound

Search



dis is six cropped

DiS is 6! Our 66, part 3

no votes
?
by Mike Diver

My, you’re patient sorts, dearest DiS faithful. We ran part two of our run down of DiS’s favourite/most inspirational/bestesteva albums almost two weeks ago, and yet you’re still champing at the bit to find out who has, and more importantly who hasn’t, made it into the top twenty of Our 66. Well, the time has come to quit your champing: we’re here, this is the penultimate countdown.

Just t’other day we ran our pick of the records that so narrowly missed the cut for Our 66 – click here if you’re yet to read that Idlewild and Animal Collective won’t feature below. As you can see from the quality of the albums that were ultimately omitted, reaching the point where a concrete top twenty was in place required the spilling of no little sweat; blood, too, may have seeped from our pores as we deliberated over the long-players that mean the most to us, that touch us there. You know where: that place that’s tickled and tingled only ever so rarely, by the music of mere mortals who dare to tear the fabric of time with compositions that will never, ever go out of style. Their significance won’t wane, and while not every album listed below is a massive-selling affair, each and every selection has made the top twenty because we can’t live without it.

These are records that inform and influence our behaviour day in, day out; they are records that comprise substantial foundations for the towering, out-of-control being that DrownedinSound.com is becoming. These are albums that each and every DiS reader, be you a regular, message-boarder or complete first-timer, should bend an ear toward; these are albums that excel in too many areas for such brief read-them-below blurbs to do anything like justice to. But maybe that’s the point to this: we don’t want to tell you why you should love these albums, we just want you to hear what we hear and come to your own conclusions. We want to share our most precious loves, our obsessions, with you. So DiScuss our choices, please.

The top six will be revealed next week, once we’ve properly formulated a plan of how to best present them to you: simple summarisations simply won’t do for the records we’re keeping back. They’re the bioelectric lifeblood that courses through DiS’s digital veins. This, we’ve said before though, way back in Part 1. So enough with the introduction: read on and enjoy…

Part 1 of Our 66 is here, Part 2 here, Writers Choice here, and 20 That Missed The Cut here. Remember, you can submit your own reviews of any of the below albums – just click where it says ‘review’ or ‘listing’. You can also add the albums to your online collection by following that simple instruction and clicking where indicated.

Words: Colin Roberts (CR), Raziq Rauf (RR), Mike Diver (MD), Sean Adams (SA)

---

20
Explosions In The Sky
How Strange, Innocence
(DiS listing)
(Temporary Residence/Bella Union – released 2005)
Imagine swimming, in a drunk-dream, into a whirlpool only for a whale to toss you from the water while you’re desperately trying to swim down into the geyser-ing fountain shooting from its blowhole. If you can picture yourself coming up for air and opening your eyes and gliding through deep space with nothing but stars for company, then maybe you can imagine what this sounds like. It’s maybe the most uplifting, close-your-eyes-and-float-away record of the last six years. Any uninitiated readers with a penchant for Sigur Rós are advised to obtain this immediately. SA


19
Cat Power
You Are Free
(DiS review)
(Matador – released 2003)
Chan (pronounced Sean) Marshall isn't your average girl with a guitar. She doesn't want to be your friend, least of all your hero; she simply wants to help herself and the rest of the world feel and deal with the ache of modern life. For all the pain which was poured into this, her best album to date, there's a sense that she had a renewed hope in the world whilst also finding her voice, and then some. Despite the fact she could be singing anything with that amaretto-soaked breathy-husk and your average indie fan (read also: indie boy) would go weak at the knees, it’s her lyrics – rich in playful metaphors and stories which can break 'n' heal your heart - that make this album one of the best of the last six years. You Are Free puts Chan at the forefront of the singers and songwriters of our generation, and also sets her apart as one of the inspirational female icons in contemporary music. SA


18
My Morning Jacket
Z (DiS review)
(BMG – released 2005)
Wig out! Massive chorus! Heart-wrenching quiet bit! Massive crescendo! Hair bigger than Cedric & Omar! All of these things make up Z: not only My Morning Jacket’s most accomplished work thus far, but also an astounding achievement overall. Doused in stadium reverb, but with the kind of intimacy you’d expect from a solo acoustic record, Z is quite simply a MASSIVE album, the scope of which is only actually outstripped by the eventual execution. From the bass rumble of the opener ‘Wordless Chorus’, through fields of delay and joy, the album would plot a glorious bar graph, all the way until ‘Dondante’ hits the breathiest of quiet depths, before erupting in one of the most evocative musical mushrooms you can imagine. Skyward-facing introversion coupled with a penchant for soloing and accomplished musicality ensures Z a rightful place in Our 66. CR


17
Cursive
The Ugly Organ (DiS listing)
(Saddle Creek – released 2003)
Like an instrumental revelation, The Ugly Organ comprised Cursive’s evolution from respectable (and certainly likeable) hardcore kids to widely revered and adored songsmiths and musicians. Lyrically angry, musically untouchable and texturally thick as hell, The Ugly Organ introduced the cello as a viable instrument in rock n’ roll. Tim Kasher’s pained vocal inflections and wry outlook upon life exaggerated what could have been a musically-engrossing LP that lacked integrity into a fully-loaded package that still surprises at every twist and turn. Personally, it never ceases to amaze me, and I live in hope that in years to come it will be looked back upon as the classic I consider it to be. CR


16
Radiohead
Kid A (DiS review)
(EMI – released 2000)
There was an unholy level of expectation building prior to the release of this, piling atop a band that had not only become an outfit seminal to a generation of indie kids, but who had also expanded beyond national treasure status to become a worldwide success. After 1997's OK Computer, Radiohead had become the new pretenders to the crown that Nirvana had vacated - they hated it just as bloody much as their predecessors. Resenting their worldwide smash hit of 'Creep' and stepping away from the formula that’d informed their previous three albums so brilliantly, Radiohead did everything they could to create a brand new, totally unrecognisable masterpiece. After receiving mixed reviews it seemed as though they had succeeded in stumping the critics at first, but over time this has become yet another classic in the band’s canon of work. RR


15
The Murder Of Rosa Luxemburg
Everyone’s In Love And Flowers Pick Themselves
(DiS review)
(Undergroove – released 2003)
Any album that can simultaneously strike fear and joy into the soul of the listener is one to behold, and the sole (almost) Long-player from Worcester’s greatest-ever band is guilty of this pleasure and so much more besides. From the penetrative death swell of ‘Slap the Cubo-Futurist’ to the blissful instrumental meanderings of ‘Jack and Oscar Have a Fight’, this is a record so pure in its arrangements and yet so blindingly adventurous that it leaves the work of many other guitar bands floundering in its wake. Sadly disbanded, The Murder Of… live on in this writer’s heart as one of the most important bands of the personal growing-up process, musically not physically – it acted as a perfect stepping stone to things harder, more electronic and more ‘out there’. CR


14
Saul Williams
Saul Williams (DiS review)
(Wichita – released 2005)
Hip-hop has rarely meant much to me during my lifetime – too young to be swept up and away by the politick of Public Enemy and too old, beyond my fresh face, to be swung by any of that gangsta braggadocio, I was an indie-rocker through and through, raised on a steady diet of the products of angry punks dissatisfied with their lots. They weren’t bigging anyone up or shouting anyone down – they were laying their arses on the line for a necessary dose of reality. Saul Williams was the first album to have an impact upon me on a deeply personal level that wasn’t exclusively driven by riffs and solos. This is the life so real you daren’t even dream it set to rough beats and boisterous sirens, the voice that shines through the fog one that simply won’t be silenced by convention or cliché. This is hip-hop that strides beyond hip-hop, beyond the expected and the tried-and-tested; this is hip-hop like I’d never heard it before. And I’ve never stopped listening to it, and learning from it, since. MD


13
Four Tet
Rounds (DiS review)
(Domino – released 2003)
Or: how to make exclusively instrumental music that lasts for a neat forty-five interesting – nay, heart-stoppingly arresting and inspiring – in one easy lesson. Rounds may not possess a human voice, but within its staccato beats and flurries of cymbal rushes, its grandiose orchestral swoops and microscopic click-click symphonies, lies every organ that you or I call our own. Press an ear close to a cone during Rounds and you’ll feel a breath, constant and unfaltering, on your cheek; hold two fingers to the cable that connects stereo to speaker and a pulse is easily detectable, regular and reassuringly human. Kieran Hebden managed with Rounds something that he’d failed to wholly realise with its preceding long-play brethren: a true connection between man and machine was achieved, and ever since he’s been struggling – if we’re being absolutely fair – to produce material that is so instantaneously engaging and emotionally affecting. Still, even if no future Four Tet albums successfully merge biological brainwaves with electric pulses and crackles, we’ll always have this: Rounds is a timeless masterpiece that simply can’t be categorised conventionally and refuses to lessen in brilliance with endless repeat plays. MD


12
The Icarus Line
Mono (DiS listing)
(Sweet Nothing – released 2001)
I’ve no memory of what it was I had all bottled up inside o’ me prior to hearing this, but once I returned from a weekly shopping trip to the local town I called ‘almost home’ in my early 20s and slipped this little unassuming beauty into my stereo, it fucking exploded across my bedroom like a wonderful rainbow of middle-finger fuck-yous and acerbic, barely-discernable lyrics about who-cares-what. A plain compact disc and no song titles on the record’s sleeve gave little away: Mono kept its many trump cards well hidden ‘til it was absolutely necessary to release them, violently and spectacularly. The first twelve seconds of ‘Love Is Happiness’ – the first twelve seconds of the record, full stop – acted like a fist-in-the-face wake up: forget all the posers and the half-hearted in-it-for-the-moneys, as this had The Real Deal stamped all over its jaws like little before or after it. This was the breaking of a humungous punk-rock wave, the crushing devastation that followed just part of the essential purification process. After Mono, no ‘punk’ band could ever call themselves such without fucking substantial evidence. Mono makes me want to fight a policeman whenever I hear it – it’s the aural equivalent of Popeye’s spinach ingestion, and keeps me on edge from start to finish. Steer clear if black eyes aren’t your thing. MD


11
Interpol
Turn On The Bright Lights (DiS review)
(Matador – released 2002)
The ‘what’s the best Interpol album’ debate raged long and hard at DiS: this, or the Tim Burton-ish otherworldly and UFO-esque Antics? Their debut – this – proved that the four-piece were the coolest, bravest and most innovative new band in New York at a time when the city’s kids, and those across the ocean, were squeaking feverishly about retro-rock bands, many of which are notably absent from this list. Interpol went against the jangle-rock grain when they introduced this searchlight-in-a-catacomb indie-pop record to the world. For every rigid Joy Division-ism there's an epic dancefloor pleaser - 'PDA' for one! And for every milligram of head-pumping joy, there's a perfectly-balanced expansive post-rock flavoured nod to the life-death line, where mortality becomes a bleak streak of big black sunglasses across the face of our high-rise, low self-esteem, anticipation-driven, accelerated realities. Put succinctly: a must own. SA


10
Ryan Adams
Heartbreaker (DiS listing)
(Lost Highway – released 2000)
There aren’t words, expressions or movements that I could use to sum up what Heartbreaker means to me. An album that upon a cursory listen could be summarised-cum-dismissed as a solid alt-country effort and nothing more, Heartbreaker’s layers upon layers of song craft slowly reveal themselves as Ryan’s soul is laid bare on the table, his heart jumping off his sleeve and into your conscience. Personally, I am incapable of thinking of a better album from the last six years, an album that can do all of this to me and still be an album that is listenable at the dinner table with the family and equally perfect for a drunken sing-along with friends. Ryan’s solo career began with this masterwork: it’s hard to imagine him bettering it –though he’s come damned close – and in my mind this album is his passport to ‘legendary’ status. The greatest songwriter of our generation? No question, personally. CR


9
Bright Eyes
Lifted or The Story Is In The Soil, Keep Your Ear To The Ground
(DiS review)
(Wichita – released 2002)
There are few musicians active during DiS’s lifetime as important as Conor Oberst. Like most of us, he's tired and weary of the ways of the modern world, yet tirelessly he attempts to make sense of the myths and the madness. Within Lifted... there's the sense Conor put down his punk-cock acoustic handbook, quit his moaning and decided to aurally encapsulate a sidestepped world within which he wished we bathed and lived. Some might call it a coming of age, some just that it represents the end of his growing pains. Gone was the often close-to-embarrassing student poetry; in came gigantic statements, luscious usage of metaphors and arrangements built for much bigger things. One of the many addictive extras was the wonder with which this was assembled as a body of work - it ebbs with production suss, with moments of changing rooms and dementia. You can throw as many Neil Young/Bob Dylan comments-cum-references at Conor as you like and raise a bar based in an old world, but the times have changed and this is the howl of now. It’s the result of a truly godless, science-spirited, civil-less global society of superstars and nihilistic escapism never previously seen nor lived through. If folk told stories and punk broke the capitalist status quo then this was the first truly heart-broken expression against futuristic poverty on a globally visible scale. SA


8
And You Will Us By The Trail Of Dead
Madonna (DiS listing)
(Domino – released 2000)
Here’s a dare for you, try it at home whydon’tcha: pluck this record from whatever rack it rests upon while silent, place it neatly inside your CD player/onto your record deck, and remain perfectly still for the duration of first track proper ‘Mistakes And Regrets’. Can’t be done, seriously – don’t think I’ve not tried, ‘cause I wouldn’t have challenged you to execute such a command if I hadn’t already failed to achieve a statuesque state myself. Each and every time I play this album, my body simply spasms itself into a sweaty heap; I wind up crumpled in a position that even a Moscow State Circus contortionist would require three years’ training to pull off on a regular basis, with no memory of how I got there nor any particular inclination to remedy the intense ache such a situation spreads from toe-tip to split end. Somewhere about the ten minutes from home mark I recall being subjected to the substantial uppercut that is ‘Perfect Teenhood’, but I think I passed out totally around the eightieth “fuck you”. Successfully stay still during that first song, though, and I’ll buy you lunch. Really. Once I manage to unwind my arm from around my lower colon, anyway. MD


7
The Shins
Chutes Too Narrow (DiS review)
(Sub Pop – released 2004)
Few bands can lay claim to anywhere near as much CD player hi-jacking time over these past six years than The Shins, be said player’s owner a founder of DrownedinSound.com or the female lead in the film Garden State. Choosing between The Shins’ albums to date is a tough enough call, but we've opted for the saccharine sunshine and hook-filled bird of prey-like melodies of this, the quartet’s second long-play offering. There are many reasons why this record became an obsession to many, but for me it's mostly James Mercer’s lyrics that keep me coming back: they’re some of the most metaphorically humbling, gently sentimental, profoundly human and downright beautiful words anyone has ever written. It is a great modern tragedy that the Albuquerque-spawned and Oregon-based outfit are not the biggest band in the world today, but things could be worse: any self-respecting fan of music that doesn’t eventually discover and become smitten with this knowingly dumb-grin joy of a record surely knows the true feeling of tragedy. Chutes Too Narrow is an absolute triumph of an album. SA


---


The final part of Our 66 will run next week; in the meantime, DiScuss



Nice to see Four Tet in there.

And My Morning Jacket.


Very surprised...

(but pleased) that Kid A was only 16th.

Great to see Cat Power there, personally one of my favourites. As with Ryan Adams and Interpol. Great to see The Shins feature highly too.

However?

Madonna's awesome, but better than Source Tags...?

And Lifted...? Better than Fevers & Mirrors, or I'm Wide Awake...? I don't think so.

Also, Domestica > The Ugly Organ... but that one's very close.

I love Z too.

So, yeah, very good list. Here's hoping to see David Thomas Broughton in the top six...


can't argue

with a lot of that

Lifted by Bright Eyes - a big YES to seeing that in there.


fuck bright eyes

that's the absolute worst album on this whole list - well, maybe slipknot is worse, but this comes pretty close


I feel the The Shins

are massively over-rated on here. I've got the album (and like it) but really can't see why they are revered so much. To me they make nice pop tunes, but there's nothing particularly amazing or original about it.

7/10 tops.


Murder of Rosa Luxemburg!

GET THE FUCK IN! It's wonderful that people are starting to see it for just how bloody fantastic it is.
Can't go wrong with EITS or Bright Eyes, good choices...
Interesting choice of Trail Of Dead album, but it was gonna be either that or Source Tags And Codes, and they both rock mightely, so well done. I'm also happy to see Kid A in there, at that position. Seems about right.


Nice pop tunes

= Reason enough, but there's so much more to them too


id replace shins with MMJ

but good list overall


still looking really good

the shins definitely deserve to be in there.


Kid A below the Icarus Line!?!?!?

And Bright fucking Eyes? Have you all gone completely insane!?

Oh dear oh dear oh dear.

Oh dear.

The top 6 had better be pretty damn special now ;-)

</friendly banter>


that's a good list!

id agree with pretty much everyone of them

except i cant believe you chose how strange, innocence over the earth is not a cold, dead place!


i agree...

id have chosen another EITS album...


I prefer fevers & mirrors

but if it is in the top 6 i'll forgive you


Only one album per artist.

Also, "Letting Off The Happiness" beats "Fevers and Meers" into a cocked hat


oooh

i don't agree with this bit of the list. most of my favourites were earlier, and shoulf be swapped over and that...


shirley

at dawn is better than z...and it's impossible for saul williams to be higher than radiohead. no, no. but otherwise, yay for interpol, bright eyes and heartbreaker for those albums are all beast.


All of my top 6 albums

have either been featured already, not made the cut, or just won't be in the final 6 :(
Put The Neon Handshake in there please :D
Or Racecar is Racecar Backwards
Or Horse Of The Dog
Or either of the Million Dead albums
Or either of the Oceansize albums.

I reckon at least Relationship Of Command and Silent Alarm will be in the final 6. Mmmmmaaaybe something by Mew, I don't know.


Frengers...

...has already been in hasn't it?


No.

well it had better be.


guessing

bloc party, flaming lips, delgados, atdi, arctic monkeys, qotsa. how was the list decided?


vewvbvt

no chance for flaming lips or delgados.

my guess would be:

atdi relationship
bright eyes i'm wide awake
bloc party silent alarm
65daysofstatic fall of math

and 2 others! maybe interpol antics. and something else


HOW MANY TIMES!

Only one album per artist


good point

i'll let myself off because they wrote it quite small


yeah but

they put both mars volta albums in there

My guess
Relationship of command
funeral
The Fall of Math
Return to cookie mountain
silent alarm
yoshimi


..

no they didn't


OK fine

they didnt. I just check now - but I swear the first time I read the list, that both Mars Volta albums were in there. Maybe it got edited. Spooky.......


Only one album per artist

Nothing has been changed, silly!


Im scared now

Really I am. This is far too spooky


funeral

funeral has already been too. i couldn't believe it either


sean apparently didn't like it is what colin said earlier

I think its good, but since I got into broken social scene, I find it hard to listen to arcade fire in the same way. I hope the new album sets me on fire though.


it's not that i dont like it

it's that I think it's an unemotional sack of crap that has been hyped in the most ridiculous and disproportionate manner. i've listened to it so many times but it just feels like a album of bored people making time changes.


i'll let you in on a secret

only 2 of these feature.


uh no

also one time for all time is approximately four times better than the fall of math. even though retreat! retreat! is a very fantastic song i think await rescue is better and so is the whole album overall


WILCO?

yankee hotel foxtrot!


!

oh my god yes. it hasn't been on any of the lists so far and if it doesn't make the cut, my god will there ever be hell to pay.


TOBTL only at 11?

Crumbs, good to Trail of Dead so high. Have been adoring that album again recently


*see


ho ho ho

You gave Kid A a 4/10 when it came out. Now its 16 in the top 66 albums of the last 6 years.

I aint saying nothin'.


yes, because

one writer reflects the views of EVERYONE at DiS.

tart.


this is my favourite section of the 66 so far

best trail of dead album, best shins album, kid a is my fave radiohead...

and icarus line, though I'm surprised you didn't go for penance soiree. I guess mono is more of an aural hand grenade though.

and the EITS and the bright eyes are both the best records they ever made in their careers.


penance soiree

is gash; "look we do drugs and want to support Primal Scream 4evah!!!" can't touch "white-knuckle oblivion of youth burning up" - yay for Mono!

PMFS, SFTF and el-p haven't made the 86 though so i'm clearly well out of joint with the DiS vibe...


when did fuck with fire come out?

it maybe should have been considered... ah well.


...

22nd of May, 2001...


.

You're stringing this poll out waaaaaaaay too much


are we?

Would you really want all 66 in one hit?
The article would be so big my FACE would collapse.


It should have been

presented by Jimmy Carr on Channel 4 over two nights


i want the murder of to be higher!!

boo hiss.

mind you, i suppose not many people have heard it


Relationship of Command

for number 1. I don't know what's left that would effect DiS as much as that album.


surprised

kid a wasn't higher


Bright Eyes and The Shins

the two most overrated artists in the indie world.


Wow

Out of the other two put together I only have 4 albums, out of this one I have 6. I'm a little surprised.

That said, I tried to get into Murder ORL and never really did. Maybe I'll go back in time and have another go.


screw opinions

just listen to the music and ACTUALLY DANCE when you go to a gig!!!


excellent

ryan adams. yep. heartbreaker is a truly exceptional album... i don't know, i might have put cold roses as my ryan pick, but what the hell. the guy appears to have an inability to release a bad album (anyone mentions rock and roll and they DIE).


Rock and Roll

sorry.


kerpow


rock n roll

is brilliant, i love it.


hmmm

good choice of Cat Power album, bad choice of EITS.


please

dont put bloc party in the top 6. please


hmm

this is ridiculous, what about britney spears, christina aguilera, justin timberlake, lance bass, and clay aiken? are you guys serious?


.

Agreeing with most of this so far, esp. Ryan Adams, Interpol and The Shins. Although maybe TOTBL should be top 6?

Silent Alarm has to be Top 6 afaic. Everytime I go back to that record I love it even more.


^^^

YES, TOTBL would probably be my number 1

:)


Z? no! no, no, no!

it's got some nice moments but it's definitely the most heavy-handed of all MMJs albums. jim james sounds like a hollering brickie at times, i swear. where's the beauty? It Still Moves or At Dawn are easily better.


At Dawn

is fucking ace


soooooo

Absolutely worthy artists on here:
Explosions in the Sky, Cat Power, My Morning Jacket, Radiohead, Four Tet, Interpol, Ryan Adams, Trail of Dead, The Shins

Not worth the time of day:
Cursive, The Murder of Rosa Luxembourg, Saul Williams, The Icarus Line, Bright Eyes

9 to 5 is a pretty good ratio - nice job, DiS


no silent alarm

if silent alarm is in the top 6 i couldnt take this list seriously.

im sure Dis posted a story a while back about how the NME was forced to change its top albums of the year (putting silent alarm at 1 instead of arcade fire). surely Dis isnt under the same pressures? probably not, but i cant explain why silent alarm could be above funeral, or EITS (wrong album totally, HSI was released somewhat reluctantly) or about 50 other albums...but maybe im just crazy


lolz

the icarus line and the murder of... albums are two of my favourite albums of all time... so im chuffed to see them up there... it will be interesting to see the top6


i'm still waiting

for Richard Cheese - Lounge Against The Machine


come on

knowing how retarded and musically ignorant most DiS staffers are, the absolutely fucking dire McClusky Do Dallas (or whatever the fuck that pile of musical bilge is called) has to be in the top5, and I say this: You're not thirteen! You don't have to be seen to like it! Grow the fuck up and start voting for Doves. Btw, if anyone disagrees, go fuck your sister, k?


my sister is hot

but i'm still not going to fuck her just because you said so...

mclusky are skill (they've got more songs than a song convention). listening to Doves isn't growing up - it's being po-faced and dull, dull, dull.


explosions in the sky:

after having read that brief snippet of a blurb, i'm going out and buying it immediately, oh my oh my!


Explosions in the Sky

is a brilliant band! I'm glad to see the made the list.